The peace agreement between Eritrea and Ethiopia raises hopes that human rights will be at the centre of Eritrea’s path
towards a society respectful of all fundamental rights, says the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights
in Eritrea, Sheila B. Keetharuth.
The leaders of the two countries signed a Joint Declaration of Peace and Friendship on 9 July 2018. They have reaffirmed
it on several occasions since then, raising expectations that the end of the 'no war, no peace' stalemate between the
countries would impact positively on Eritrea’s internal human rights situation.
The arrest of 11 senior Government officials who had criticised the President’s actions in an open letter, and that of
10 independent journalists, thus silencing analytical discussions and the private press on 18 September 2001, set off a
period of sweeping oppression in Eritrea. Reportedly, such repression continues, quashing the aspiration for tangible
improvements in its human rights record.
“During the past 17 years, the Government of Eritrea has maintained tight control over the country, stifling any form of
public debate and participation. I have received reports that the former Minister of Finance, who recently wrote two
books on the current state of affairs in the country, including the rule of law, has been arrested in Asmara during the
morning of 17 September 2018. If confirmed, this arrest on the eve of the anniversary of the 2001 clampdown would add to
the apprehension that improvements in Eritrea’s external relations are not mirrored inside, especially regarding respect
for fundamental rights and freedoms,” said Ms Keetharuth.
“Comprehensive reforms at the domestic level are required on the path towards a free, just and democratic society, with
citizens enjoying all their human rights,” the expert stressed, “yet, Government can take immediate action in three
concrete areas, where urgent rectification is most needed.”
Firstly, the families of those who have disappeared in Eritrean prisons should be informed about the fate of their loved
ones. Furthermore, the large but unknown number of people imprisoned in Eritrea, some for excessively long periods and
others arrested more recently, should be brought before the courts of law as a matter of urgency or released
unconditionally without delay.
Secondly, the implementation of the Constitution that has been pending since 1997 would be the natural basis on which to
build a solid national legal framework and a society governed by the rule of law.
Thirdly, thousands of Eritreans have left the country because of violations committed in the context of
national/military service. With the end of the ‘no war, no peace’ context that served as a justification for the
indefinite nature of national/military service, the Government could inform those who have been enlisted as conscripts
recently that they will not have to serve beyond the 18 months stipulated by Eritrean law. For those in the
national/military service for lengthy periods already, the Government should elaborate a demobilisation plan without
further delay, especially for long-serving conscripts.
“The achievement of peace between Eritrea and Ethiopia must be duly celebrated. However, Eritrean authorities must
urgently embrace and implement bold measures to strengthen protection of and respect for human rights, justice and
accountability,” the UN expert concluded.