INDEPENDENT NEWS

Silly Season Timing Perfect for Intelligence Rep.

Published: Tue 28 Dec 1999 12:18 AM
AZIZ CHOUDRY,
PO BOX 1905,
CHRISTCHURCH
27/12/1999
Media Release For Immediate Use
Silly Season Timing Perfect for Annual Intelligence and Security Report.
“Turkey, Chicken or Just Plain Stuffed” ?
The third annual report of the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, retired High Court Judge Laurie Greig, tabled in Parliament last week, has come under fire from one of the first people to lay a complaint against the SIS with the Inspector-General.
“It’s pathetic. I can’t believe that someone actually got paid for writing this!” said Aziz Choudry after reading the 20-page document.
“I know it’s the silly season. But its bland assurances about the operations of the SIS and the GCSB and its self-congratulatory tone are bizarre, inappropriate and disturbing given Laurie Greig’s failure to adequately explain his conclusions that the actions and procedures surrounding the botched, illegal 1996 SIS break-in at my house was “lawful reasonable and justified” when the
Court of Appeal ruled the break-in to be illegal”.
“Indeed it was the Inspector General’s June 1997 whitewash of the SIS break-in and refusal to state whether or not SIS agents were involved which forced me to take a civil case through the courts.”
In his annual report, Mr Greig asserts that: “I believe that we can congratulate ourselves on being able to operate Security and Intelligence Services effectively and appropriately for the benefit of New Zealand as a whole on such a small scale.”
“Yet in correspondence to me following last year’s Court of Appeal ruling he conceded that his conclusions were based “in part, on an erroneous view of the law.””
“The Inspector-General’s report on my complaint appears to have been as botched as the bungled SIS break-in. And his annual report fails to acknowledge this failure in any way.”
“At a time when the new government is running hot with the rhetoric of accountability in the public sector and a fairer society, I can’t make my mind up as to whether the best description of the intelligence agencies and the supposed mechanisms of oversight is turkeys, chickens, or just plain stuffed,” he said.
“The oversight and review mechanisms are merely cosmetic. They are there for show – not effect.”
“1999 has seen the powers of the SIS greatly expanded with the passage of legislation which legalised an illegality supported by all parties except for the Greens and the Alliance. This report adds further weight to criticism levelled at New Zealand intelligence agencies that they remain unaccountable and a law unto themselves”.
Mr Choudry has no illusions that things will improve under the new Government.
“The Alliance has repeatedly called for an inquiry into SIS operations and its leader Jim Anderton has stated that he is opposed to the existence of the SIS. But Helen Clark actively dissuaded David Small and I from taking further action against the SIS after we had expressed our dissatisfaction with the Inspector-General’s findings, and has been unsympathetic and indeed hostile to concerns raised by a wide spectrum of New Zealanders about the role of the SIS. Indeed it is difficult to see the difference between Labour and National on this issue.”
For further comment: ph. Aziz Choudry at (03) 3484763
I

Next in New Zealand politics

Refreshed Cabinet line-up confirmed
By: New Zealand Government
Better Funding Needed For Community Law
By: Community Law Centres
Wellington bus network troubles blamed on city's challenges
By: RNZ
Gordon Campbell on the public service reforms
By: Gordon Campbell
Excessive force used during public disorder in Huntly
By: Independent Police Conduct Authority
New report shows household emissions increasing
By: Statistics New Zealand
End of Life Choice Bill passes second reading
By: RNZ
Primary teachers vote for settlement
By: NZEI
Video: PM reveals first substantive Cabinet reshuffle
By: RNZ
Comment on reshuffle from Phil Twyford
By: New Zealand Government
Housing needs a single Minister, end to KiwiBuild
By: ACT New Zealand
Cabinet reshuffle: Yet another working group?
By: New Zealand Taxpayers' Union
Government fails to take animal welfare seriously
By: SAFE
Delivering certainty for Community Law Centres
By: New Zealand Government
NZ First Delighted with Support for Community Law Centres
By: New Zealand First Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media