Arguments Against Civil Unions Echo Opposition to Inter-racial Marriage
Recognition of same sex and de facto couples is the next historic step towards a more just society according to
Christians for Civil Unions, a broad Christian network that supports the law change. They compare civil union
legislation to legalizing inter-racial marriage, which was also once considered ungodly and unnatural.
Spokesperson, Rev Dr Margaret Mayman, told the Select Committee hearing submissions on the Civil Union and Relationships
Bill today that the arguments used by opponents to civil unions were the same religious and social claims used to oppose
inter-racial marriages in the United States in the 1960s. “They argued that God created the races separate and did not
intend for them to mix and that inter-racial marriage would disrupt society and the sanctity of marriage,” she said.
Citing the US Supreme court case of Loving vs Virginia which overturned laws against inter-racial marriage in 1968, Dr
Mayman reminded the Select Committee that apparently reasonable people argued at the time on grounds that now seem
incomprehensible but were then considered both biblical and common sense. “I believe that there will come a day when
people will look back on the civil union debate with similar incredulity,” she said.
Christians for Civil Unions includes a wide range of Christian individuals, congregations, and church leaders from the
Anglican, Baptist, Brethren, Roman Catholic, Methodist, and Presbyterian Churches and includes Maori, Pakeha, Pacifica
and other immigrant people.
The submission also addressed the narrow biblical interpretation cited by some people opposed to the bills. “While there
are six passages of scripture that condemn homosexual acts, it is important to recognise that homosexual orientation was
unknown in biblical times. The biblical writers assumed that everyone was heterosexual and that people engaging in
homosexual acts were going against their God-given nature,” Dr Mayman said.
Christians for Civil Unions believes that the Bible is far more concerned about peace and economic justice than it is
about regulation of sexuality. Civil Unions will have real benefits for society through the legal protection and social
recognition for same sex and de facto couples and social acceptance for children from diverse families.