Peter Dunne Insults Sick Medicinal Cannabis Patient
Dear Sir,
I run a support group for those with a genuine medical need for cannabis. Doctors are required to sign forms attesting
to the benefit of cannabis for their patient.
Recently I wrote to UF s Peter Dunne. Below is a copy of my letter to him and his reply I received today. I really
wonder if he accidentally included this response to me as well as his collegues. Surely it would be in the public
interest to publish the way in which Mr Dunne treats and communicates with the sick. If you can make a story out of the
following please do so. If you simply wish to publish the letter followed by Mr Dunnes reply you have my permisson to do
so.
Regards
Greg Soar – Auckland, NZ
-------
Peter Dunnes E mail Reply
This garbage is not worth replying to
Hon Peter Dunne MP for Ohariu Belmont Leader, United Future
UNITED FUTURE - FOCUSING ON FAMILIES
More information at www.unitedfuture.org.nz
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My Letter to Peter Dunne
-----Original Message----- From: gc soar [mailto:gcsoar@ihug.co.nz] Sent: Monday, 11 August 2003 10:13 a.m. To: Judy
Turner Cc: Peter Dunne; Paul Adams; Judy Turner; Gordon Copeland; Marc Alexander; Bernie Ogilvy; Murray Smith; Larry
Baldock Subject: Medicinal Cannabis - from a dying person Importance: High
Greg Soar Coordinator GreenCross Medicinal Cannabis Support Group of NZ Inc. P O Box 27 209 Mt Roskill Auckland 1004
11th Aug 2003
Judy Turner United Future Health Spokesperson Parliament Buildings Wellington.
Dear Ms Turner,
GreenCross has been in contact with UF regarding medicinal cannabis since late 2002. We met with Paul Adams in March
2003 to provide evidence from our doctors and other sources attesting that cannabis is helping our health problems. Mr.
Adams chose to insist cannabis once damaged someone and would never change his mind about cannabis / medicine. He was so
emphatic about not changing his mind he repeated himself three times during the conversation. This is very far from
taking the time to examine proper evidence. When I pointed out people were suffering and dying Mr. Adams stated " don't
be so dramatic there are other things you can use".
My dear friend Evan Clive Shephard lived with HIV. He was so sick when he took his medications. Severe nausea to the
point he couldn't eat. His life was one long nausea session. More than once I was with him in public when he suffered
severe diahorrea resulting in extreme embarrassment. Evan smoked cannabis when he could obtain some. It stopped his
severe nausea dead in its tracks. No prescribed medications were able to do this. Unfortunately for Evan he could not
afford cannabis so mostly went without. The medications were so nasty he chose a better life not taking the meds
realising his time would be shorter but at least more enjoyable. Evans immune system depleted so badly due to his
inability to stomach HIV medications he began to have lesions form in his brain. Toxoplasmosis is a nasty virus. My dear
friend Evan lost his ability to talk, then his ability to walk and finall
I myself have the same nasty effects and currently my HIV medications are failing due to inability to stomach them. My
cd 4 count is down to 54 and my viral load sits at 4.2 . I am afraid to say that I am losing the battle for the reasons
stated. I would be willing to try Marinol at this point but my own specialist told me that at a conference he recently
attended that to many people report an acute high. My specialists name is Dr Rick Franklin of the Auckland Sexual Health
clinic and you may indeed check with him as to what I have said regarding Marinol.
If United Future and / or Paul adams are aware of these " other drugs" we can use then why have we not been told what
they are? GreenCross made several phone calls to Mr. Adams offices over the six months since the meeting only to never
be given the courtesy of a response let alone an answer. Our members are upset Mr. Adams knows of medication better than
cannabis yet makes us suffer by not informing us of what they are. We can only conclude one of the following.
1. Paul Adams / United Future does not want to help us. 2. Paul adams / United Future was wrong about the other drugs
and should therefore reconsider the statement and opinions on medicinal cannabis.
Could United Future please supply us the names of these drugs or apologise to our members. We wish to work with United
Future on this issue and an apology or drug naming would serve to placate some of our members who suffer daily.
During the meeting with Paul Adams I felt he was genuinely surprised when told that the sick are not medicating but
actually going without. Too many people especially MP s seem to be of the impression we can have cannabis already albeit
illegally. This is not true due to the cost. The sick are often on benefits and cannot afford $150.00 per week to
medicate with. The prohibition of medicinal cannabis really does cause suffering.
As you are aware the Health Select Committee into cannabis recommends the use of medicinal cannabis. Again I have been
receiving a flood of calls from our members [ membership means a registered medical practitioner has signed forms
attesting the benefits of cannabis]. All of them have been in regard to your press statements along the lines of those
mostly wanting medicinal cannabis are the social pro legalisers. This is offensive to those of us who face death and
depleted quality of life from severe illness and who have doctors backing medicinal cannabis use but are left to go
without the product for lack of ability to afford black market prices. Will you please inform our members as to how you
arrived at such a conclusion.
We are all decent members of this society and deserve to be heard. In a press statement dated Aug 5 2003 you asserted
cannabis use leads to methamphetimine use. This is not true and there are both international and local studies debunking
the long held gateway theory. We feel that you have deliberately mislead the house.
GreenCross Medicinal Cannabis Support Group formally ask that you honour your role as an MP and apologise immediately
for your attempt to mislead the house and members of New Zealand society. Education and advancement in social / medical
policy can only be based upon truths. Anything less is indeed a crime.
Finally could United Future give their response to the fact doctors are signing forms attesting to the benefit of
cannabis for their patient. Put this in context with your comments about the proponents of medicinal cannabis being pro
legalisers and I am sure even you must admit why we feel so offended and utterly devalued of any worth.
I repeat that GreenCross Medicinal Cannabis support group wish to work with United Future on the issue and look forward
to open and honest dialogue. Our members will not however sit quietly by when contemporary propaganda is exercised.
Sincerely
Greg Soar