INDEPENDENT NEWS

Clark admits new speech laws won’t prevent violence

Published: Tue 14 May 2019 09:12 AM
Former Prime Minister Helen Clark’s proposal for more robust hate speech laws is a solution looking for a problem, according to ACT Leader David Seymour.
“On Q+A this evening, Clark admitted that protecting religious groups from hate speech wouldn’t have prevented the Christchurch terrorist attack.
Her own Foundation’s report, released tonight, says ‘…it is difficult to establish a causal link between online hate speech and violence.’
“Why, then, do we need additional laws that would further undermine New Zealanders’ right to freedom of expression?
“New Zealand already has tools available to deal with speech that incites violence or offences which are targeted at particular groups.
“Adding new groups to our hate speech laws will create division and further criminalise speech.
“Just in the past few weeks we’ve seen Hobson’s Pledge the subject of a complaint to the Human Rights Commission, a One Law for All pamphlet denounced by the Justice Minister, and an anti-Islam pamphlet investigated by Police. This shows how easily hate speech laws could become weaponised.
“Besides, it isn’t obvious that religion should be treated in the same way as race. Race is an immutable characteristic, whereas religion is a set of ideas. We shouldn’t restrict debate about, and criticism of, religion.
“The idea that a government agency should make arbitrary judgements of what is and isn’t a reasonable opinion for people to express is counter to the Bill of Rights Act, which says: ‘Everyone has the right to freedom of expression, including the freedom to seek, receive, and impart information and opinions of any kind in any form.’
“If the Government broadens our hate speech laws, we will see more New Zealanders hauled before authorities for expressing their political views. That would be deeply divisive.”

Next in New Zealand politics

PM's Post-Cab 27/5/19: Mental Health Inquiry and the Budget
By: The Scoop Team
New service for young people leaving care
By: New Zealand Government
Too many youths on remand being held in secure facilities
By: RNZ
NZ On Air and RNZ launch new Local Democracy Reporting
By: NZ On Air
On coal’s negative message to today's school protest
By: Gordon Campbell
Police officer should not have engaged in pursuit
By: Independent Police Conduct Authority
Targets overlook the 174000 children living in worst poverty
By: Child Poverty Action Group
Barnardos praises Budget 2019 youth investment
By: Barnardos
The PSA welcomes transition support package
By: Public Service Association
State of Care: Supporting young people on remand
By: Office of the Children's Commissioner
NZ Maori Council comes out swinging
By: New Zealand Maori Council
Almost 200 youth offenders held in police cells
By: RNZ
Students stage “lie in” before strike
By: School Strike 4 Climate
Youth groups collaborate to Elbow Elders for climate action
By: Generation Zero
NZEI Te Riu Roa supports student action on climate change
By: New Zealand Educational Institute
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media