Goff Supports Limited Exception To Double Jeopardy Rule
Justice Minister Phil Goff will support a Law Commission proposal to allow for a limited exception to the rule against
double jeopardy in a narrow class of cases.
Justice Baragwanath has made the recommendation in his report 'Acquittal Following Perversion of the Course of Justice'.
The paper was in response to the case of gang member, Kevin Moore, who was unable to be retried for murder after his
acquittal on his first trial because of false evidence by a witness.
"I support the general rule against double jeopardy where a person cannot be re-tried for the same offence. But where
the accused has secured an unmerited acquittal on a serious charge by perjury or other conduct that has perverted the
course of justice, an exception to the rule is warranted.
"Not to change the law in this area risks bringing the justice system into public contempt. Also, it would provide an
incentive for those accused of serious offences to commit perjury or otherwise pervert the course of justice.
"In the case of Moore, he benefited from his own abuse of the criminal justice system. He should have got at least ten
years for murder. But as a result of witness perjury he may serve as little as two years and four months for the lesser
charge of conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.
"He has literally gotten away with murder.
"The rule against double jeopardy is a long-standing aspect of our law and an important protection of the administration
of justice.
"I note Justice Baragwanath's recommendations that the exception to the rule only apply when the accused is guilty of an
administration of justice crime such as perjury and that the original crime must be confined to the most serious classes
of case.
"I will be putting a paper to cabinet for a law change recommending a limited exception to the rule against double
jeopardy," Mr Goff said.
ENDS