INDEPENDENT NEWS

Fletcher sued for $7.5m over Christchurch justice precinct

Published: Mon 7 Oct 2019 04:46 PM
Fletcher Building is being sued for $7.5 million by utilities contractor Electrix, one of the subcontractors on the Christchurch Justice and Emergency Services Precinct.
The NZX-listed company lost more than $400 million constructing the facility for the Ministry of Justice. It finally opened in September 2017.
The High Court at Auckland heard today how Electrix had worked on the project for more than three years and was paid approximately $21 million. However, it claims it should get another $7.45 million for work that it did.
The case, set down for several weeks, will shed light on what happened with the multimillion-dollar project which caused losses to Fletcher’s building and interiors unit.
Electrix’s lawyer Kelly Quinn told the court that Fletcher is also embroiled in another dispute over the project with Opus, but that matter was not central to Electrix’s case. This was hotly disputed by Fletcher’s lawyer Kerry Fulton who said that was speculation which was not supported by evidence.
Fletcher is counterclaiming against Electrix, saying that it had actually overpaid the engineering firm which is ultimately French-owned. It says it should have only paid Electrix $14 million.
In opening submissions before Justice Matthew Palmer, Quinn explained that the Electrix claim was not in contract, but quasi-contract or the legal doctrine of quantum meruit.
“If work is done in expectation of a contract, and done in circumstances where the defendant knows or ought to know that the plaintiff wishes to be paid - which is going to follow 99 percent of the time - then the plaintiff should be paid a reasonable sum for the work done,” Quinn said.
Electrix had said in its tender documents it could do the job for $16.9 million, but says that more work was required after the ministry rejected the detailed design for the electrics, setting the project back.
Further letters of intent sent by Fletcher show that the NZ-listed company wanted to further contract with Electrix, Quinn claims.
Fletcher’s lawyer is to present the company's counterclaim later in the proceeding.
As the subsidiary of foreign firm Vinci, Electrix is required to file its financial statements to the Companies Office. They show it posted a profit of $5.9 million in calendar 2018 on revenue of $250.4 million.
BusinessDesk
Independent, Trustworthy New Zealand Business News
The Wellington-based BusinessDesk team provides a daily news feed for a serious business audience.
Contact BusinessDesk
Email:

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Government accounts show strong economy
By: New Zealand Government
OceanaGold cleared to buy land for Waihi tailings expansion
By: BusinessDesk
PHARMAC signs bundle deal for more cancer medicines
By: PHARMAC
Government levels electricity playing field for consumers
By: New Zealand Government
NZ dollar rises on better-than-expected govt surplus
By: BusinessDesk
Rail revaluation bolsters Crown 2019 accounts
By: BusinessDesk
Shane Jones' PGF quietly made tax-exempt
By: BusinessDesk
Robertson’s pockets bulge as everyday Kiwis struggle
By: New Zealand National Party
DHB deficits out of control, health services at risk
By: New Zealand National Party
Green Party responds to Government surplus announcement
By: Green Party
Nearly $2 of every $5 swallowed by the Government
By: ACT New Zealand
NZEI Te Riu Roa welcomes Government's education spending sig
By: NZEI
Give the money back, Grant
By: New Zealand Taxpayers' Union
Surplus should be spent on housing, health and services
By: Public Service Association
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media