Commercial property stocks a better bet than Auckland houses, broker says
By Sophie Boot
June 9 (BusinessDesk) – Housing investors would be better off putting their money in commercial property stocks, which
provide higher yield than the slowing residential market, a broker says.
Investing in residential property is “a terrible waste of money”, with yields far less attractive than the share market,
according to Hamilton Hindin Green investment adviser Jeremy Sullivan.
"Fundamentally things are looking pretty stretched, and to be honest residential property has had a great run over the
last decade," Sullivan said. "Prices in Christchurch have been largely flat for the last three years, sales volumes are
falling and the engine room Auckland is running out of puff. The recent loan-to-value ratio restrictions put on by the
Reserve Bank have seen landlords either being told to deleverage or that they cannot continue to build their property
portfolio."
In Christchurch, where median rent is $388 per week and pre-tax yield is 4.52 percent, a taxpayer in the 33 percent
bracket would see net yield just above 3 percent, Sullivan said. That doesn't include an average 1.35 percent each year
for rates, insurance and maintenance, or the cost of a property manager. In contrast, listed commercial property
investors such as Goodman Property Trust and Argosy Property return yields between 6-and-8 percent each year.
Sullivan said with net migration easing and building consents having overtaken population growth, “even someone with
rudimentary knowledge of economics can guess what is going to happen next” to residential property while investing in
listed commercial property provides more liquidity and diversity, and the stocks are modestly leveraged meaning
investors take less risk.
Data from state-owned valuer Quotable Value earlier this month showed property values increased 9.7 percent in May, the
slowest pace in two years, or 7.4 percent when adjusted for inflation. In Auckland, where surging values have made
housing unaffordable for many, regional house values rose 9.3 percent to an average $1.04 million, the slowest annual
rate since November 2014.
Yesterday, the Reserve Bank said limiting mortgage lending at a debt-to-income ratio of five times would make an
appropriate addition to the macro-prudential toolkit it could call on to prevent a housing market crash. The bank's work
estimated of the 78,200 mortgage-funded purchases in a year, 10,400 high DTI transactions would be blocked by a
restriction, of which 8,800 would be investors.
(BusinessDesk)
ends