VUW Hosts Exhibition Glorifying Ukrainian Fascists
By Tom Peters.
Victoria University
of
Wellington (VUW) is currently hosting an
installation
designed to promote the US-NATO proxy war
being waged by
Ukraine’s military against Russia, while
whitewashing the
Ukrainian regime and its fascist
supporters.
The
exhibition, titled “Ukraine: The
Cost of Freedom,” was
exhibited in the Auckland War
Memorial Museum during
September and October, before
moving to Wellington last
month.
The display
at VUW was mounted by the
Ukrainian Gromada of Wellington
(UGW). This group is
affiliated with the Ukrainian World
Congress (UWC), a
network of organisations founded in
1967 in New York to
oppose the Soviet Union from the
standpoint of right-wing
Ukrainian nationalism and
anti-communism.
Since
Russia’s invasion of
Ukraine in February 2022, the UWC has
served as an
important propaganda arm of Volodymr
Zelensky’s regime,
staging rallies and raising funds for
Ukraine’s war
effort, while demanding more direct military
action
against Russia by the US and NATO.
The UGW,
along
with the Ukrainian Association of New Zealand, is
calling
for the Labour Party-led government to expel
Russia’s
ambassador, and to provide more funding, weapons
and
training for Ukraine’s armed
forces.
Jacinda
Ardern’s government has already
declared its
“unwavering” commitment to the war
against Russia and
has sent more than 200 soldiers to
help train Ukrainian
forces in the UK, gather
intelligence, and coordinate
supplies for the
war.
The exhibition at VUW falsely
depicts the
Ukrainian regime as the blameless victim
of
“unprovoked” Russian aggression aimed at
“denying
Ukraine its statehood and
killing
indiscriminately.”
Vladimir Putin’s
invasion was
certainly reactionary: it has led to
thousands of deaths,
along with rampant inflation that is
devastating millions of
people throughout the world. The
war, however, was
deliberately prepared and instigated by
the US and NATO,
which have for years militarily
encircled Russia, carrying
out military provocations, and
in 2014 supported a coup in
Ukraine that overthrew a
pro-Russian government.
The
coup is glorified in
the VUW exhibition as a “Revolution
of Dignity”
carried out to integrate Ukraine into the
European Union.
It was led by far-right US-backed forces,
which brought
to power a viciously anti-Russian government.
This
sparked a civil war with the eastern provinces of
Donetsk
and Luhansk with large ethnic Russian populations,
and
Russia’s annexation of Crimea.
The
long-standing
aim of US imperialism is to counter its
economic decline by
securing its domination over the
entire Eurasian
landmass—with its vast natural
resources and working class
population—even if this
means war with both Russia and
China.
A central
aspect of the VUW installation is its
glorification of
the Azov Battalion, a fascist militia
founded following
the 2014 coup, which has been integrated
into Ukraine’s
military and promoted, trained and funded
by the US and
its allies.
A wall panel states: “Azov
Battalion,
praised as ‘our best warriors’ by President
Petro
Poroshenko (2014–2019) became part of our
National
Guard under government command. Putin then
played upon and
inflated Azov’s far-right links with
false propaganda
about Ukrainian ‘Nazi’
government.”
While
admitting that Azov was
founded by “a person with
far-right views,” the text
claims that the
organisation’s “radical core” has
been diluted by the
influx of new fighters. This
assertion is not backed up by
anything and flies in the
face of reality.
Azov, along
with other militias
like the Right Sector’s Ukrainian
Volunteer Corps and
the country’s military leadership
itself, is teeming
with fascists, racists and anti-Semites.
Its founder
Andriy Biletsky is a white supremacist who in
2010 stated
that Ukraine had a mission to “lead the white
races of
the world in a final crusade … against
Semite-led
Untermenschen [subhumans].”
Azov
forged links with
other neo-Nazi and white supremacist
organisations
internationally, including the Rise Above
Movement and the
Atomwaffen Division in the US, and has
played a significant
role in recruiting foreign fighters
for the Ukraine war. The
militia uses Nazi symbols,
including—until a recent
rebranding—the Wolfsangel
used by Hitler’s SS, and the
Black Sun, which was used
by terrorist Brenton Tarrant, who
massacred 51 people in
two mosques in Christchurch, New
Zealand in March
2019.
Like the Ukrainian government,
the Azov
Battalion promotes Stepan Bandera as a national
hero. As
the leader of the Organisation of Ukrainian
Nationalists
(OUN), Bandera collaborated with the Waffen SS
during
World War II in carrying out the Holocaust in
Ukraine.
The OUN viewed Nazi Germany as an ally in the
struggle to
restore capitalism to Ukraine and break from the
Soviet
Union.
The VUW exhibition includes a
picture
of Bandera alongside a map of Ukraine, with two
other OUN
leaders, Yevhen Konovalets and Roman Shukhevych.
During
World War I, Konovalets led the Sich Riflemen,
which
began as a unit of Ukrainian soldiers within
the
Austro-Hungarian army. He played a leading role in
the
operation to crush the January 1918 uprising of
workers in
Kyiv supporting the Russian
Revolution.
Shukhevych was
a leader of the OUN’s
armed wing, the Ukrainian Insurgent
Army, which directly
participated in the massacre of tens of
thousands of
Poles and Jews in WWII. He was also a commander
in the
Nazis’ Nachtigall Battalion, and a deputy commander
of
the Schutzmannschaft 201 auxiliary
police
battalion.
None of these facts are explained
in the
exhibition, which presents a right-wing
nationalist version
of Ukraine’s history aimed at
relativising the Nazi
Holocaust.
Under the
subheading “~7 mil. Ukrainian
lives paid to win World
War II,” the wall text declares:
“The world knows
about the atrocities of Hitler, but many
do not realise
that his regime was just an ambitious student
that
surpassed (arguably) its real teacher, Stalin and
his
Soviet killing machine.” The text falsely equates
the
actions of the Soviets and the Nazis in Ukraine,
saying that
both sides showed “especial hatred towards
ethnicities
deemed unwanted and massacred.”
The
“History of
Ukraine” panel does not mention the
genocide of the Jewish
people by the Nazis (assisted by
the OUN). Nor is there any
acknowledgement of the
decisive role played by the Soviet
Red Army, which
included about 4.5 million Ukrainian
soldiers, in
defeating the Nazi war
machine.
The claim
that Stalin was the
“real teacher” of Hitler, with
the implication that the
Soviet Union bears
responsibility for the Holocaust, is part
of an extreme
right-wing narrative promoted during the 1980s
by Nazi
apologists such as Ernst Nolte in Germany. More
recently,
these claims have been repackaged by propagandists
for US
and German imperialism against Russia, such as
Jörg
Baberowski and Timothy Snyder.
While leaving
out the
Holocaust, the VUW exhibition presents right-wing
propaganda
that the Soviet famine of 1932–33 was a
genocide, or
“Holodomor” (death by starvation), of
the Ukrainian
population which “Stalin designed, and
Soviet servants
eagerly conducted.”
The famine
killed about 7
million people across the Soviet Union,
and while Ukraine
suffered disproportionately with 3.5
million deaths, there
is no evidence to suggest there was
a deliberate plan by
Moscow to kill Ukrainians. It was
primarily the outcome of
the Stalinist bureaucracy’s
disastrous agricultural
policies, including forced
collectivisation in the
countryside. The persecuted Left
Opposition led by Leon
Trotsky condemned these policies,
which were the outcome of
Stalin’s reactionary
nationalist program of building
“socialism in one
country.”
Stalin represented the
nationalist
reaction against the 1917 Russian Revolution. He
led a
privileged bureaucracy, which consolidated its
power
during the 1920s and 1930s through the mass
murder,
imprisonment and exile of Left Oppositionists who
fought to
preserve workers’ democracy in the Soviet
Union, and to
defend the internationalist program of
world socialism that
underpinned the revolution.
In
lurid anti-communist
language, the “Cost of Freedom”
exhibition states that
the founding of the Soviet Union
in 1922 led to Ukraine
being “imprisoned by
Bolsheviks” and oppressed by a
“Red horde of seasoned
soldiers infected with promises of
wealth
redistribution.”
In reality, the 1917
revolution
was an uprising of millions of workers and
peasants,
including in Ukraine, against the tsarist
empire.
Millions subsequently joined the Red Army to
defend the
gains of the revolution against imperialist
intervention
during the Civil War.
As the WSWS has
explained,
“the Soviet Union, based on workers’
power, was deeply
committed to the defense of the
democratic and national
rights of all the nationalities
that had been oppressed by
the tsarist regime. The
bureaucratic degeneration of the
Soviet Union,
personified in Stalin’s rise to power,
found
particularly acute expression in the violation
and
suppression of the legitimate democratic aspirations
of the
national minorities within the
USSR.”
Today, both
the Ukrainian and Russian
regimes share an intense hatred of
socialism and the
working class. Three days before launching
the invasion
of Ukraine, Putin gave a lengthy speech which
glorified
the tsarist regime and denounced Vladimir Lenin
and the
Russian Revolution for “creating” the
Ukrainian
state. The oligarchies represented by Putin and
Zelensky
enriched themselves through the looting of
state-owned
property following the Stalinists’
dissolution of the
Soviet Union in 1991 and the
restoration of
capitalism.
The war in Ukraine, in
the final analysis,
is the outcome of the break-up of the
Soviet Union. This led
to the creation of intensely
nationalistic states across
Eastern Europe, serving as
military outposts for NATO and US
imperialism. Meanwhile,
the working class across the region
suffered a
catastrophic decline in its standard of living
due to the
evisceration of social programs.
Now,
millions of
working people face an ever-expanding war whose
purpose
is to defend, on one side, the profits of the
Russian
bourgeoisie, and on the other, those of the US and
NATO
imperialists and their puppets in
Kyiv.
The
fact that Victoria University of
Wellington and the
Auckland War Memorial Museum have
provided a platform for
extreme right-wing propaganda in the
service of the
US-NATO war against Russia must be taken as a
warning by
students and young people. As is the
case
internationally, universities in New Zealand are
being
transformed from places of learning and objective
historical
research into centres for the promotion of war
and
right-wing ideology.
VUW is playing a central
role. In
August 2019, its Centre for Strategic Studies
hosted a talk
by NATO secretary-general Jens Stoltenberg,
who hailed the
military build-up in nations bordering
Russia, and denounced
“China’s role and influence”
as another “threat”
to the “rules-based order”
dominated by US imperialism
and its allies. A few months
later the university hosted a
presentation by Anne-Marie
Brady, a prominent NATO-funded
academic who has demanded
more open support from Wellington
for the US-led military
build-up against China.
The
current exhibition is a
continuation of this campaign aimed
at integrating New
Zealand more closely into the US war
drive. This requires
the relentless demonisation of Russia
and the
whitewashing of fascism in Ukraine. It also entails
the
falsification of history in order to smear the
Russian
Revolution, which brought an end to the First
World War and
charted the path for abolishing the source
of war: the
capitalist system and its division of the
world into
antagonistic nation states.
The study of
the Russian
Revolution is indispensable for young people
and workers who
are seeking the means to prevent a
catastrophic third world
war involving nuclear-armed
powers. As was the case in 1917,
building an anti-war
movement today requires a revolutionary
socialist
strategy to unite the working class in every
country,
including Ukrainian and Russian workers, against
their
capitalist rulers.
We call on students at VUW
and
other universities in New Zealand to oppose
the
pro-imperialist propaganda barrage. Join the
International
Youth and Students for Social Equality
(IYSSE), which is
fighting to build a global anti-war
movement, based on
socialist and internationalist
principles.
Read and
share our statement, “A call
to youth throughout the
world: Build a mass movement to
stop the Ukraine war!” and
attend the IYSSE’s global
webinar on December 11 at 7 a.m.
New Zealand time: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/11/04/pers-n04.html