“Four experts from Newcastle University’s School of Dental Sciences have done us all a favour by speaking the truth and
smashing the latest lie against vaping,” says Nancy Loucas, Executive Coordinator of the Coalition of Asia Pacific
Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA).Nancy Loucas, Executive Coordinator, CAPHRA.
Her comments follow a claim in the British Dental Journal that vaping causes tooth damage. The claim was made by two
food science lecturers at the Cardiff Metropolitan University School of Sport and Health Science.
A letter has since been published in the British Dental Journal by Newcastle University vaping and dentistry experts Dr
Richard Holliday, Professor Elaine McColl, Anthony Weke, and Zella Sayeed debunking the claims out of Cardiff.
The four wrote they ‘were disappointed to see several basic errors and misrepresentations’ and went onto correct five
major errors in the ‘erosive potential of vaping’ paper.
“The United Kingdom has adopted a relatively progressive and risk-proportionate approach to vaping, with Public Health
England resolute that vaping is 95% less harmful than smoking. The fact that two food science lecturers were able to get
their claims published in the first place is surprising, but thankfully they’ve now been sent down the road,” says Ms
Loucas.
Newcastle’s quartet of experts say the authors cite a WHO poster and incorrectly claim that nicotine causes a 'high risk
of oral and whole-body health complications'. In reality, nicotine has been used in the form of NRT for over 30 years,
including in pregnant women, and is regarded as extremely safe, even for long-term use
Also significantly, the authors wrongly claim that e-cigarettes are associated with cancer. The supporting reference
does not make this claim and in fact states 'no long-term evidence related to oral and systemic health effects exist'.
The Newcastle experts then ‘point UK dental professionals to the well-considered public health guidance which basically
concludes that, for the best chances of quitting smoking, one should use support and pharmacotherapy and that
e-cigarettes can be part of that package’.
CAPHRA notes that in The Times newspaper last month restorative dentistry and periodontics specialist Dr Richard
Holliday wrote ‘smokers who are thinking about switching to an e-cigarette should bear in mind that this is a great move
for their general and oral health’.
“The food science lecturers’ biggest mistake was one made by so many – that is talking up the WHO’s anti-vaping stance
as the official public health position. Tellingly, all UK public bodies, including the NHS, ignore the WHO’s advice.
They support vaping, knowing it does not erode teeth nor lead to gum disease.
“Once again science and human evidence have trumped another untenable ideological lie about vaping,” says Nancy Loucas.
Boasting over 15,000 testimonials, CAPHRA is calling on those who’ve quit cigarettes through smoke-free nicotine
alternatives to tell their story on www.righttovape.org
For a free digital media repository on tobacco harm reduction in Asia Pacific - including media releases, images and
graphics - please visit https://apthrmedia.orgAbout CAPHRA
The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Advocates (CAPHRA) is a regional alliance of consumer tobacco harm reduction
advocacy organizations. Its mission is to educate, advocate and represent the right of adult alternative nicotine
consumers to access and use of products that reduce harm from tobacco use.