Defending the environmental defenders
Shobha Shukla, CNS (Citizen News Service)
Violations of the environmental rights of communities and individuals are on the rise in Asia Pacific and worldwide.
Statistics released by Global Witness reveals that in 2017, 197 people were killed (on an average 4 per week) for
defending their land and/or natural resources, underscoring the escalating violence in a global economy that is driven
by expansion and consumption through corrupt and unjust practices. Extractive industries were one of the deadliest
drivers of violence.
Also around 40-50% of all victims globally come from indigenous and local communities who are defending their lands, and
their access to natural resources which they depend on for survival and livelihoods.
WOMEN ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENDERS ARE VULNERABLE
Women environmental defenders are especially vulnerable, and are prone to multiple and intersecting forms of
discrimination. They are being threatened and even killed when they speak up against the corporate aggression directed
at natural resources.
Intensification in killings is related to intensification of exploitation and plunder of the natural resources.
The current neoliberal economic development model gives corporations the power to take over the people and their
“Philippines, along with rest of South-East Asia, is abundant in natural resources, thus becoming a hotspot for foreign
investors, especially in mining, logging, and industrial agriculture. It has the biggest mono crop plantations,
especially of oil palm and rubber, built for export. So while the country is rich its people remain poor. They are not
benefitting from their own natural resources. This has lead to conflict situations and people’s uprising. In fact
Philippines, with 41 deaths, was the most murderous country for environmental defenders in the whole of Asia”, bemoans
April Porteria, programme coordinator at Centre for Environmental Concerns Philippines, and civil society representative
from Asia Pacific for UN Environment Programme (UNEP).
CLIMATE JUSTICE IS INTEGRAL TO SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Talking of climate justice, Toan Tran, Programme Manager at Centre for Sustainable Rural Development, Vietnam, feels
that it is about protecting people’s rights and using the natural resources in a sustainable (and not exploitative) way.
Governments should reform and implement policies for protecting the environment, increasing coverage of forest area,
conserving bio diversity, and ensuring safety of the ocean environment. Toan also holds to account patriarchal
societies, like that of Vietnam, for limiting grassroots women’s participation and decision making in activities of the
community. However, she is optimistic that things are changing, albeit slowly. In Vietnam, feminist participatory action
research has succeeded in developing women’s capacities and building their confidence to cope with climate change and
disaster risk reduction. In fact 60 women from 12 villages qualified to be inducted into the Village Rapid Response
Teams (RRT), which previously had only male members. These team members prepare the community people in coping with
IT IS NOT JUST ABOUT SAFEGUARDING NATURAL RESOURCES, IT IS ALSO ABOUT PROTECTING OUR PLANET
The exploitation of extractive industries has a very negative impact on the environment. Recalls Urantsooj Gombosuren,
co-founder and chairperson of the Centre for Human Rights and Development, Mongolia, that when her mineral-rich country
made a transition to market economy in the 1990s, it needed foreign investors for whom the only attractive sector was
mining. So the government issued around 1500 licenses, mostly to transnational mining companies, without paying adequate
attention to enforce environmental laws. Irresponsible activities by the mining industries resulted in degradation of
the environment—encroachment of pasture lands, depletion of water resources, and pollution resulting in health hazards.
Urna feels that, “When environmental pollution increases it increases women’s burden too. If nearby water is polluted,
they have to travel greater distances in search of clean water sources, if people start getting sick, it is the women
whose work as caregiver increases. They also have to bear the social costs of mining—increased alcoholism in the
menfolk—who start drinking a lot after a hard day’s work—leading to increased violence, crime, prostitution and
Urna advocates for a middle path. She agrees that countries do need some minerals. But they must be extracted keeping
people’s needs in mind and not just for profit alone. So permission should be granted to just a few good companies who
meet the international standards, respect the rights of the local communities, and follow the national laws. Some of the
national companies in Mongolia have contributed in local infrastructure development by way of building houses for the
workers and schools for their children. But their numbers are few and far between. Most companies simply extract and
leave nothing behind except destruction of the environment.
With a little foresight, extractive industries can be made to work in a responsible way to help sustainable development.
Local communities should be equal partners and be able to follow, monitor and assess fulfillment of all obligations of
the industry regarding environmental and social issues. Civil society too can help in stopping unmindful/unrestricted
extraction. In Mongolia civil society has helped in improving the legal environment around mining by getting good laws
and policies in place. People now can make claims for their rights in the courts and/or with the local governments, and
demand public hearings on certain issues, which was not there earlier. Now they are starting a campaign to stop
unnecessary mining and take irresponsible companies to account.
DEFENDING PEOPLE'S ENVIRONMENTAL RIGHTS IN ASIA PACIFIC
Within the context of increasing competition for diminishing natural resources, indigenous communities, grassroots
organizations, and individuals in the Asia Pacific region are increasingly asserting their environmental rights. This
was evident at the one day workshop titled ‘Defending People’s Environmental Rights in Asia Pacific’ organised recently
in Bangkok, Thailand, just ahead of the Pacific Peoples' Forum and the 5th Asia-Pacific Forum on Sustainable Development
2018 intergovernmental meeting. Participants at the workshop shared experiences and strategies to advance environmental
rights and protect environmental defenders, and to explore and build partnerships between them. Solidarity of
environmental defenders, especially grassroots communities at the forefront, is the need of the hour. To quote Rachel
Cox, Global Witness Campaigner “Until companies, investors and governments genuinely include communities in decisions
around the use of their land and natural resources, the people who dare to speak out will continue to face violence,
imprisonment and loss of life”.
Shobha Shukla, CNS (Citizen News Service)
(Shobha Shukla is the Managing Editor at CNS (Citizen News Service) and has extensively written on gender and health
justice issues. Follow her on Twitter @Shobha1Shukla, @CNS_Health or visit www.citizen-news.org