UN Chief & Nikki Haley Should Condemn UNHRC Official’s ‘Fake Investigation’ of Venezuela Record
November 30, 2017 – UN Watch today called on UN chief Antonio Guterres, human rights commissioner Zeid, and U.S.
ambassador Nikki Haley to condemn a “fake investigation” of Venezuela's human rights record by a UN human rights council
official known as a cheerleader of the Maduro regime
Alfred de Zayas, installed in 2012 to the Cuban-created
U.N. post of “Expert on promotion of a democratic and equitable international order”, is the first U.N. human rights
council expert to be allowed in to Venezuela, and was warmly welcomed and embraced in Caracas this week by Venezuelan
foreign minister Jorge Arreaza.
"By contrast, the Maduro regime has rejected repeated requests
by the UNHRC monitors on arbitrary detention, freedom of assembly, freedom of speech, independence of the judiciary,
and arbitrary executions," said Hillel Neuer, executive director of the Geneva-based non-governmental human rights
"Zayas has used his UN post to spread overt propaganda
praising Venezuela’s Maduro regime. He is a long-time defender of Fidel Castro
and a hero to Holocaust deniers
for his writings accusing the World War II allies of committing 'genocide' against Germany," added Neuer.
UN Watch was the first to challenge Zayas
in the plenary of the UNHRC, and in an op-ed
that documented his unsuitability to be a UN expert.
Zayas is the first UN expert to be allowed
into Venezuela since 2002. A coalition of 50 Venezuelan NGOs sent an open letter
to Zayas in advance of his visit urging him to set a precondition that Caracas allow in the other UN investigators. He
Many Venezuelan NGOs expressed suspicion
about the visit and called on Zayas to meet with human rights defenders and speak out for Maduro’s victims while in the
Foreign Minister Arreaza Embraces Zayas
Arreaza greeted Zayas warmly with smiles and handshakes, hosting a meeting
with him at the Foreign Ministry. Arreaza has already used the visit to spread government propaganda, seeking to
deflect blame for the humanitarian crisis engulfing the country. The meeting was followed by a press conference
, a government press release
and multiple tweets
by the Foreign Ministry (@CancilleriaVE), and was widely covered in the press.
One self-serving tweet
proclaims that Zayas “will soon meet with the people’s power without any kind of restriction.” It is unclear who this
is referring to, but there is no indication that Zayas met with political prisoners or opposition leaders.
The Maduro regime clearly views Zayas as an ally. According to Arreaza, the pro-Castro U.N. expert was invited—even as
Venezuela denied entry to other UN experts—during the September 2017 Human Rights Council Session. This was a
transparent bid to deflect criticism of the Maduro regime by UN rights chief Zeid Hussein, whom Arreaza accused
of attacking Venezuela.
The fact that de Zayas is cozy with the regime is no secret. In the September UNHRC session, Zayas sat on a Venezuelan-chaired panel
of pro-dictator UN experts who attacked the West and defended Venezuela. Also on the panel were Jean Ziegler, Cuba's initial nominee
for Zayas' post, and founder and recipient of the now-defunct “Qaddafi Human Rights Prize”; and ex-Algerian ambassador
Idriss Jazairy, who took $50,000 from Russia and then issued a report claiming that the Putin regime is a victim of
Arreaza’s remarks following the meeting with de Zayas
On economic sanctions against Venezuela, Arreaza said
that Zayas was concerned about “the financial blockade against Venezuela and the way our debt is being used to block
access to resources for social investment for Venezuelans.”
On the political violence in April and July, Arreaza lauded
his government for responding with “democracy” to the opposition’s use of “the street, pain and death to justify – as
in 2002 – a change of government by force.” This, after 163 protesters were killed and 15,000 injured
in anti-government rallies in 2017, and the government stripped the National Assembly
of its legislative powers.
Zayas fails to condemn Maduro’s crimes
Instead of using the visit to hold the Maduro regime to account and demand change, as UN experts are supposed to do,
Zayas reportedly acknowledged
Maduro’s efforts to “promote peace” through “national dialogue.”
Not surprisingly, the government press release
concluded with a statement that it expects Zayas to issue a UN report reflecting his “balanced and rigorous opinion on
the Venezuelan reality.” Russia likewise received a positive report from Zayas’ close ally, UN expert Idriss Jazairy.
Zayas’ own UN press release
about his Venezuela visit confirms that he is aligned with the government and has no intention of speaking out for
Maduro’s victims. He says that his visit will be about promoting “social progress” and “better standards of living,” and
researching the impact of global civil society on “investment in food, housing, health and education programs.”
Meanwhile, Venezuelans face mass hunger with 75% of the population
having lost weight in 2017 (some as much as 78 pounds), girls as young as 12
being forced into prostitution to feed their families, acute malnutrition
rising from 8% to 12% in the first half of 2017, and record high levels of malaria
which is not being adequately treated due to lack of medicine.
Zayas’ press release also suggests Venezuela’s human rights catastrophe is the making of outsiders, not the Venezuelan
government, stating “human rights and development cross borders in today’s globalized world,” and there is a need to
“strengthen relationships to overcome obstacles” to civil liberties.
His press release omitted mention of the Maduro regime’s many crimes, including jailing political prisoners, silencing
of opposition leaders, torture and killing of protesters, and causing mass hunger.