PHILIPPINES: Black Tuesday protest over new Cyber Crime libel law
MANILA (The PCIJ Blog/Pacific Media Watch): Media organisations and netizens in the Philippines marked the 28th
anniversary of the EDSA "People Power" Revolt this week with a Black Tuesday campaign to protest the Cyber Libel
provision of Republic Act 10175 - or the Cybercrime Prevention Act.
The Supreme Court last week declared the Cyber Libel provision of R.A. 10175 as constitutional, effectively expanding
the coverage of the country’s 80-year-old libel law into the digital domain.
Media and online groups have protested against the ruling, saying the decision reverses what already appeared to be a
libertarian trend in the courts in the interpretation of libel laws.
Libel is defined in Article 323 of the Revised Penal Code as a criminal offence, punishable with both a prison term and
damages. Media and lawyers groups have been pushing for the decriminalisation of libel, saying the law has been used to
harass and intimidate the Philippine press.
In addition, the Philippines is unique in that an allegedly libelous statement is presumed to be malicious until proven
otherwise by the accused. This implies that the accused is already presumed to be guilty until he proves himself
innocent before the courts.
Exactly a week ago on Tuesday, the Supreme Court ruled on the constitutionality of R.A. 10175s cyber libel provision,
which recognises that libel can be committed online, but only by the original authors and producers of the material.
Not included in the crime of cyber libel are those who receive or respond to the material.
At the same time the Tribunal struck down several provisions of the law as unconstitutional, particularly the
“take-down” clause which would have allowed the government to deny or restrict access to digital hardware and material
even without a warrant, and the real-time collection of traffic data.
The decision came exactly a week before the nation commemorates the 28th anniversary of the EDSA People Power Revolt,
when press freedom was restored in the country.
Media organisations have pointed out that the Cybercrime Act and the SC ruling on the law effectively reverses many of
the freedoms gained in EDSA by unduly restricting freedom of expression and freedom of the press even in the internet.
To mark this day, online groups and media organisations including the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines,
the Center for Media Freedom and Responsibility, and the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism, have declared
February 25 as Black Tuesday.
The groups are launching this noon an online protest to ask the Supreme Court to reverse its ruling on cyber libel, and
to press legislators to amend the libel provisions in Article 353 of the Revised Penal Code.
Ends