Professor Tracey McIntosh (Ngāi Tūhoe) from the University of Auckland has been announced as a commissioner on the
Government’s recently established Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC).
A professor of Indigenous Studies and co-head of Te Wānanga o Waipapa in the University’s Faculty of Arts, Dr McIntosh
is also the Chief Science Advisor for the Ministry of Social Development.
Her research has focused on incarceration (particularly of Māori and Indigenous peoples) and issues of poverty,
inequality and social justice, and she has been a regular educator inside prisons. She also has a strong interest in the
interface between research and policy and ensuring that processes are responsive to, and inclusive of, tikanga and
mātauranga Māori.
As an independent Crown Entity governed by a board of appointed commissioners, the CCRC will have a mandate to
investigate possible miscarriages of justice, with the power to refer cases back to the appeal court, but not to
determine guilt or innocence.
Māori are overrepresented in the criminal justice system, and Dr McIntosh is hoping the commission will be an
opportunity to revisit legal decisions through a different lens.
“The independence and accessibility of the CCRC is significant, and as a new entity in the criminal justice system, it’s
important that it is people-centred and not system-centred,” she says.
“The interests of justice are not served if there are miscarriages of justice or wrongful convictions. The ability to
also investigate policies and procedures that have led, or could lead to, miscarriages of justice is also important.”
Under the current system, if someone believes they have suffered a miscarriage of justice they can apply to the
Governor-General, who can choose to seek advice from the Justice Minister to exercise the Royal prerogative of mercy.
This prerogative can be used to grant a free pardon or refer a conviction or sentence back to an appeal court, and is
only usually used if relevant, fresh evidence becomes available that hasn’t already been properly examined by a court;
it can also take years to process.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission will offer applicants a much faster hearing and will operate entirely independently
of the Justice Department and the court system.
Dr McIntosh will be serving a four-year term on the commission from 15 June 2020, joining Paula Rose, Deputy Chair of
Worksafe New Zealand; criminal defence lawyer Kingi Snelgar; Deputy Mayor of Palmerston North, Tangi Utikere; QC Nigel
Hampton and health scientist Dr Virginia Hope. Colin Carruthers QC will remain the Chief Commissioner until June 2024.
Several other countries have established similar commissions, including the United Kingdom (England, Wales and Northern
Ireland), Scotland and Norway.
The Criminal Cases Review Act, which established the Criminal Cases Review Commission, will come into force on 1 July
2020. The commission will be based in Hamilton.
Editor’s notes
• Professor Tracey McIntosh was the former co-director of Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga, New Zealand’s Māori Centre of
Research Excellence.
• She has previously taught in the sociology and criminology programme at the University of Auckland and was a
Fulbright Visiting Lecturer in New Zealand Studies at Georgetown University in Washington D.C.
• She has sat on a number of assessment panels including PBRF panels (Māori Knowledge and Development and Social
Sciences) the Marsden Social Science Panel and the Rutherford Discovery, James Cook Fellowship and Health Research
Council Panels.
• In 2018-2019, Professor McIntosh was a member of the Welfare Expert Advisory Group (WEAG) which released the
report Whakmana Tangata: Restoring Dignity to Social Security in New Zealand (2019) as well as Te Uepū Hapai i te Ora, The Safe and Effective Justice Advisory Group, which released: He Waka Roimata: Transforming our Criminal Justice System (2019).