For as long as the Campaign Against Foreign Control of Aotearoa (CAFCA) has existed – more than 45 years now – we have
called for the closure of the Bluff aluminium smelter, owned by giant transnational corporation, Rio Tinto. There are
numerous grounds for doing so, all of which amount to the smelter not being in New Zealand’s national interest. The
corporate welfare power price deal (the price is still secret) by itself qualifies the smelter as the country’s biggest
bludger. Once again Rio Tinto is pulling the same old party trick of threatening to close down and leave the country
unless it gets an even better deal than what it currently enjoys.
The conventional analysis used to be that the smelter is bad for the country but good for Southland. Not so more, in
light of very recent events. Last week’s huge floods throughout Southland ran the very real risk of setting an
environmental catastrophe (not to mention a major threat to life) if the water had got into huge quantities of toxic
waste stored in Mataura, which would have released ammonia gas. Fortunately, that did not happen. But neither the toxic
waste nor the threat have gone away.
What is this toxic waste? Some (but by no means all) media reports correctly identified it as the poetically named
dross, the toxic waste product of the smelter. And why is it being stored in a closed down former papermill building
right next to a river in Mataura (along with other places dotted across Southland)? Because Rio Tinto got sick of
storing it onsite at Bluff and decided to outsource its disposal to a third-party company, which took it off Rio Tinto’s
hands in 2014 and then promptly went bust in 2016. Leaving the people of Mataura, and elsewhere in Southland, stuck with
the problem.
Following last week’s flood, the Gore District Council made a verbal deal with the smelter management to have the dross
removed. That deal was overruled by Rio Tinto’s Board. As Gore’s CEO said: “We had a deal sealed with a good
old-fashioned Southland handshake, but Rio Tinto’s bosses have reneged”. At which point the “transformative” Government
started to wake from its stupor. Environment Minister David Parker said it was “disgraceful” and “I’ve had enough” and
threatened to look at suing Rio Tinto.
Good luck with that one, Minister. That would involve Labour facing up to the 2003 and 04 indemnities signed by Michael
Cullen, Labour's Minister of Finance at the time, accepting that the taxpayer, and not the smelter owners, would be
liable for the cost of cleaning up toxic waste produced by the smelting process. That liability was renewed as recently
as 2016, by the Key government.
Yes, that’s right. Rio Tinto has outsourced the liability for cleaning up its mess onto the New Zealand taxpayer. And
supine governments, both Labour and National, have gone along with that. It’s a textbook example of a transnational
corporation privatising the profits and socialising the costs.
CAFCA suggests that the Government makes Rio Tinto clean up its own mess, at its own expense. And that the Government
cuts short Rio Tinto’s decades-long tiresome threatening to close down and assist them to do so. With a “good
old-fashioned” boot up the arse.
Murray Horton
Secretary/Organiser