INDEPENDENT NEWS

Banning unsafe cars may not improve safety

Published: Tue 18 Jun 2019 08:31 AM
Attempts to improve safety by banning the import of older vehicles may actually keep older vehicles on the road longer, says the car review website dogandlemon.com.
Editor Clive Matthew-Wilson, who is an outspoken road safety campaigner, says the government needs to remember what happened in 2008.
“With the best of intentions, the government banned vehicles that didn’t meet modern emissions standards. However, the end result was that the flow of cheap Japanese imports abruptly halted. This, in turn, meant that the prices of used cars jumped. This, in turn, meant that people kept driving their older, more polluting cars for far longer than they otherwise would have.”
“Obviously, the Global Financial Crisis of 2008 also had an effect, but the sharp drop in Japanese used imports began long before the GFC began to bite.”
“The government’s current plans to restrict the importation of Japanese imports that don’t meet modern safety standards could easily produce a similar result.”
Matthew-Wilson says that, rather than abruptly blocking a significant chunk of used Japanese imports, the government should move more cautiously.
“Many of these vehicles won’t be allowed to be imported anyway from March of next year, because they lack Electronic Stability Control (ESC). Why not let nature take its course?”
Matthew-Wilson adds that access to a reliable car is central to life outside city centres.
“You can comfortably live in Wellington without a car. You can’t easily live in a rural town without a car or motorbike. In many places in New Zealand there’s no public transport. Even when there is public transport, it’s often unsuitable for groups such as shift workers.”
“I applaud the government’s efforts to make us less dependent on private cars and to improve the safety of the vehicle fleet. However, these ideals have to be matched up to the reality. Stopping poor people buying cheap cars will not make the world a safer place.”

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on why Sustainable NZ isn’t self-sustaining
By: Gordon Campbell
Supporting all schools to succeed
By: New Zealand Government
New Zealand firefighters helping battle blazes in Queensland
By: Fire and Emergency NZ
Tighter firearms law to further improve safety
By: New Zealand Government
Police Armed Response Team in 'low level' suburban arrest
By: RNZ
Statement on Oranga Tamariki practice review
By: Office of the Children's Commissioner
Sustainable New Zealand party: Other parties unruffled
By: RNZ
Reform to support better outcomes for Māori learners
By: New Zealand Government
Tomorrow’s Schools a step too far
By: New Zealand National Party
ACT will campaign to restore school autonomy
By: ACT New Zealand
Tomorrow's Schools Review backdown must be comprehensive
By: ACT New Zealand
Secondary teachers pleased to see Taskforce recommendations
By: PPTA
Sector knowledge reflected in taskforce report
By: PPTA
Te Rito Maioha (ECNZ) welcomes education review announcement
By: Early Childhood New Zealand
NZEI Te Riu Roa welcomes direction of school system reforms
By: NZEI
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media