INDEPENDENT NEWS

Cost outweighs benefit in capital gains proposal

Published: Thu 21 Feb 2019 11:59 AM
Cost outweighs benefit in Tax Working Group’s capital gains proposal
The Employers and Manufacturers Association (EMA) says the key issue in the Tax Working Group’s proposal released today is that the cost of its capital gains tax rules will outweigh any benefits.
Chief executive Brett O’Riley says any gains from such a broad-based capital gains tax would be eaten up by administration and other costs, leaving little revenue.
"Fundamentally the proposed capital gains rules don’t address the Tax Working Group’s objectives of reducing over-investment in housing and increasing tax fairness," he says.
Mr O’Riley is also concerned that capital gains tax on business assets could discourage investment and innovation, locking businesses into their current asset holdings. He says there are other policy settings that could be changed to increase investment in different asset classes, away from property.
"I also fail to see how taxing growth on the value of assets from the proposed commencement date of 1 April 2021 would work, because it would be open to conflicting valuations," he says. "It could also act as a further disincentive to growth when New Zealand already has issues with business not growing from SME’s into larger scale operations and a CGT may also limit the availability of capital to reinvest in businesses as smaller businesses face an additional tax bill.
"It’s difficult to see any benefits for the business community from implementing the proposed capital gains tax rules, as taxing both shares and business assets appears to be double taxation," says Mr O’Riley.
It is relevant to note that a number of the Tax Working Group do not favour its recommendations on capital gains tax. The minority view summary is available here.
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

PREFU Shows Economy Doing Better Than Forecast
By: New Zealand Government
PM Statement On Cabinet COVID-19 Alert Level Review
By: New Zealand Government
Greens Unveil $297m Fund To Support Sustainable Food And Farming
By: Green Party
National Releases Its Plan To Restore NZ’s Prosperity
By: New Zealand National Party
New Zealand First Party List
By: New Zealand First Party
Arriving Travellers In Isolation To Be Able To Vote By Telephone
By: Electoral Commission
National To Invest In Our Children’s Future
By: New Zealand National Party
Numerous Arrests Following Investigation Into Historical Offending At Auckland School
By: New Zealand Police
An Extra 100,000 New Zealanders To Lose Their Jobs Under Labour
By: New Zealand National Party
New Zealand First – ‘Experience Needed Now More Than Ever’
By: New Zealand First Party
CTU Take On Pre-election Economic And Fiscal Update
By: Council of Trade Unions
PREFU Reveals Higher Debt And Unemployment, Lower Growth
By: ACT New Zealand
New Zealand First ‘Agrees To Disagree’ On Alert Level 2 Decision
By: New Zealand First Party
Alert Level 2 Continuation A Slap In The Face To New Zealanders
By: ACT New Zealand
Now Isn’t The Time To Be Making Life Harder For Farmers
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media