Federation of Freshwater Anglers
18th January 2019
The article on Newshub 16th January – ‘Opinion: No more cheap shots at dairy farmers over water quality’ by Tim Mackle
CEO of Dairy NZ is excellent and shows that he really does live on another planet.
There is no lack of understanding about what modern farming is all about when you can visibly see raw dairy effluent
running into creeks and streams.
His statement “the simple reality these days is that no dairy cow can get into a stream thanks to dairy farmers having
fenced off 97 percent of significant waterways on farms,” is complete rubbish as there are many waterways still very
accessible . He needs to stop the blame game.
We acknowledge that there are some farmers who are doing their bit to tidy up the effluent run-off into streams and
rivers and they get our applause.
However these guys are in the minority. There are a significant number of large corporate dairy farmers that have done
and are doing everything in their power to sidestep and make excuses as to why they don’t need to comply with Council
regulations, i.e.: a dutch farmer in Taupiri who owns two large dairy farms. He has been warned several times by Council
for non-compliance of feed pads and allowing vast amounts of effluent to run into drains which then run into the Waikato
He point blank refuses to resolve the issues and blames his two managers and says that it’s their fault and they should
do the required repairs which are not part of their contract and are his responsibility. They are concerned that if they
dob him in they will lose their contracts albeit knowing that they are complicit.
I also know of many other farmers that have the same attitude. There are many effluent ponds that leak, and effluent
irrigators that are operated close to and flow into drains and creeks.
Planting riparian strips is a waste of time when the land simply cannot deal with the volume of effluent.
You only need to drive around the countryside and look into the many drains and creeks to see for yourself. These drains
and creeks are disgusting and while the Councils are at fault also, you can’t take it away from these culprits.
They deserve every bit of criticism thrown at them and the attitudes of people like Tim Mackle who defend them is
shocking to say the least.
Fonterra, Dairy NZ and others that run PR campaigns telling New Zealand what a wonderful group of people they are, are a
disgrace. Instead they should be refusing to pick up the milk and break contracts of supply or run a 0800 HOT LINE
that’s protects the farm workers.
When you look back at what a wonderful state our streams and creeks were in 20-30 years ago to the degraded state they
are in now is disgraceful.
Dairy NZ and Mackle need to step up and take action against these corporates rather than defending them. Dairy farmers
have lost their social licence to farm as it’s cheaper to spend money on spin than it is to spend money on cleaning up
Mackle is correct when he says they we all need to step up, but industry and our towns are a far cry from what the
intensified dairy industry has done.
A lot of the fault lays within Council who don’t have the manpower or when staff hands are tied from taking action or
the backing of senior Council staff to penalize offenders. Farmers capitalise the cost of ‘a slap on the hand with a wet
bus ticket’ against the cost of improvements. Guess who wins.
Councils waste a lot of money on unnecessary spending when a simple marketing campaign encouraging city dwellers to wash
their vehicles on grass rather than have the chemicals flush down the storm water drains is sorely needed.