Open Request to Winston Peters for clear statement of
policy regarding US National Security Adviser John
Bolton's speech to the Federalist Society
From Leslie Bravery,
Palestine Human Rights Campaign Aotearoa New Zealand
22 September 2018
We ask you to respond to a speech made by US National Security Adviser John Bolton to the Federalist Society
on 10 September 2018, in which he outlined the Trump Administration’s clear commitment to undermine the efforts of the
International Criminal Court (ICC) to provide justice for those who are victims of alleged serious international crimes.
Mr Bolton made specific reference to Israel in the speech, criticising the possibility of an ICC investigation into
alleged international crimes committed by Israel in the West Bank and Gaza, including a possible investigation into the
construction of illegal settlements, which he referred to as ‘housing projects’. JohnBolton's speech also referred to
the United States' decision to close the Palestinian Liberation Office in Washington DC as being partly due to the PLO’s
intention to engage the ICC in a criminal investigation.
Particularly alarming were the threats made by Mr Bolton as he reached the conclusion of his speech, when he said:
“This afternoon, we also make a new pledge to the American people. If the court comes after us, Israel or other US allies
we will not sit quietly. We will take the following steps, among others, in accordance with the American Service Members
Protection Act and other legal authorities.
“We will negotiate even more binding bilateral legal agreements to prohibit nations from surrendering US persons to the
ICC and we will ensure those we already have entered are honoured by our counterpart governments.
“We will respond against the ICC and its personnel to the extent permitted by US law.
“We will ban its judges and prosecutors from entering the United States.
“We will sanction their funds in the US financial system and we will prosecute them in the US criminal system.
“We will do the same for any company or State that assists an ICC investigation of Americans. We will take note if any
countries co-operate with ICC investigations of the US and its allies and we will remember that co-operation when
setting US foreign assistance, military assistance and intelligence sharing levels . . .”
Such language expressed towards independent prosecutors, members of the judiciary, sovereign states and a
legitimately-constituted international court, dedicated to justice and the rule of law, calls into question whether the
United States remains committed to the demand for accountability for crimes that violate international law. The New
Zealand Government has a clear duty to disassociate this country from such destabilising views.
We urge our government to make clear New Zealand's position regarding our country's support for the ICC and we ask for
clear answers to the following questions:
will the New Zealand Government provide a public statement reaffirming our robust and unwavering commitment to securing
justice for victims and survivors of suspected war crimes and crimes against humanity?
will the New Zealand Government publicly express opposition to the steps announced by the US Government National
Security Adviser, Mr John Bolton, that the US will prosecute and place other sanctions against ICC personnel, including
prosecutors and Judges, and also nations or companies who support ICC investigative efforts?
is the New Zealand Government willing to urge, both directly and at international fora, that the US reverse its
opposition to the ICC and abandon the threat of punitive measures?
will the New Zealand Government declare that it supports the work of the Office of the Prosecutor of the ICC in
examining alleged serious international crimes committed in the Occupied West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and Gaza?
We also ask the Government to further affirm that such support would also extend, in principle, to a possible decision
to open any full criminal investigation.
We ask for a clear and reasonably prompt response this request, and our readers will be informed accordingly.The full
text of Bolton's speech can be read here: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/09/full-text-john-bolton-speech-federalist-society-180910172828633.html