INDEPENDENT NEWS

Judgment: M v Roper and Anor

Published: Thu 6 Sep 2018 10:01 AM
The following is based on automated text recognition. Please refer to the original PDF.
M v Roper and Anor [2018] NZHC 2330
5 September 2018
MEDIA RELEASE - FOR PUBLICATION AT 3.30 pm on Wednesday, 5 September 2018
This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court's judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at www.courtsofnz.govt.nz
Background
This judgment arises from a civil claim for damages brought by a former member of the Royal New Zealand Air Force (RNZAF) against one of her superiors, a former Sergeant Robert Roper.
The claimant, M, sought damages from Mr Roper for mental harm she alleged was caused by the bullying, verbal abuse and sexual harassment he inflicted on her between 1985 and 1988. As well as damages against Mr Roper, M sought damages against the RNZAF for failing to act on her complaints about Mr Roper and failing to take all reasonable steps to protect her. Mr Roper denied the allegations, and the RNZAF, the second defendant, denied that M had made the complaints, and that there was a failure to take all reasonable steps to protect M from harm.
I addition, both defendants argued that even if M were able to establish the alleged acts caused the mental harm for which she claimed damages, the claim could not succeed because of the statutory bar under the Limitation Act 1950 and under the Accident Compensation Act 2001.
Even if all these hurdles could be overcome, the RNZAF argued it could not be held liable, whether vicariously or directly, for any of the loss claimed by M.
Result
Edwards J found the events M said gave rise to her claim had likely occurred, albeit not with the frequency alleged. Specifically, the findings of fact established that Mr Roper assaulted and falsely imprisoned M as alleged.
The Judge accepted M suffers from symptoms consistent with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression and anxiety, as attested by expert evidence. However, in order for a damages claim to succeed in law, the Court had to be satisfied that M's experiences at Whenuapai were a "substantial and material cause of these symptoms.
After careful review of the medical evidence, and faced with M's clear presentation of a current mental injury, Edwards J found, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Roper's actions at Whenuapai were a material and substantial cause of M's current mental injury, being her PTSD.
However, the Judge found that M's claim could not ultimately succeed because M could not escape the statutory bar on bringing claims out of time created by the Limitation Act 1950, nor the provisions of the Accident Compensation Act which preclude a person from suing for compensatory damages in relation to an injury for which they are, or were, entitled to cover under that scheme.
The finding that the claim was statute-barred meant the Court was not required to consider whether or not the RNZAF could have been held liable, whether vicariously or directly, for any of the loss claimed by M.
The names, address or identifying occupations of the victim and a witness are suppressed.
Full judgment: MvRoper.pdf

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on Malaysia exposing our China policies
By: Gordon Campbell
Auckland Pride remains committed
By: Auckland Pride Festival
PM welcomes state visit by Korean President Moon Jae-in
By: New Zealand Government
Changes to drinking water standards and health
By: New Zealand Government
Police detention was unlawful but reasonable
By: Independent Police Conduct Authority
Joint Statement by Sebastián Piñera and Jacinda Ardern
By: New Zealand Government
Top academics call on government to take climate action
By: UNITEC
Gordon Campbell on NZ’s complicity in Western Sahara
By: Gordon Campbell
NZ aligned with principles not countries at APEC - Ardern
By: RNZ
Tonga and Vanuatu join China's Belt and Road
By: RNZ
US expands regional presence, part of Indo-Pacific strategy
By: RNZ
PNG foreign minister denies report on Chinese forced entry
By: RNZ
The Nation: Trade and Export Growth Minister David Parker
By: The Nation
APEC Leaders Face Challenges Together for Stronger Growth
By: APEC
PM O’Neill to Private Sector: Invest in Digital, Innovate
By: APEC
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media