Dunne Speaks: Who is Really Pulling the Government's Strings
When a few months ago New Zealand First abruptly vetoed Labour’s plans to repeal the three strikes criminal justice law
it was glibly explained away by Labour as just a breakdown in communication that would be resolved by the time a policy
paper came anywhere near the Cabinet for consideration. With the Criminal Justice Summit then looming, and clearly more
water yet to flow under the bridge, the explanation had a brief air of credibility about it, so was largely believed,
and everyone moved on.
However, it will be a little more difficult to treat this week’s equally blunt dismissal by the Deputy Prime Minister of
Labour’s long held plans to double the refugee quota in quite the same vein. All the more so, given the Deputy Prime
Minister’s accompanying chilling observation that “Labour is not the government.” This would have been news to many
people who thought we had a Labour-led coalition government with New Zealand First, and supported by the Greens.
Certainly the comments were intended to play to New Zealand First’s racist constituency that does not like either
migrants or refugees and definitely does not want to see any more of them. But they were also sending a none too veiled
reminder to Labour that this government survives neither because of the gushing charm of its leader, nor the
self-imagined talent of its Ministers, nor the will of the public, but simply and solely at the pleasure of New Zealand
First and its leader. Labour has been placed on clear public notice that it needs to toe the New Zealand First line to
remain in office. The Prime Minister’s muted response shows she understands her predicament all too well, and will bow
to it, because she has no other option.
While this was always seen as a potential risk for this coalition government, given its make-up, Labour had earlier
believed that during the period of the Prime Minister’s maternity leave, their Ministers would be able to straightjacket
the Deputy Prime Minister, to preserve the fiction this government was Labour-led, but he was too wily for that to ever
have been a possibility. This was his opportunity to put his stamp clearly on the government, and he was not going to be
denied. He easily outwitted his Labour colleagues and used his considerably greater experience to perform better than
most had expected he would as Acting Prime Minister, and bring an air of stability to a government that has looked
somewhat chaotic before and since. In so doing, he enhanced considerably his stature within the government, as well as
increasing New Zealand First's dominance of it, leaving Labour between a rock and a hard place.
By the time the Prime Minister returned to duty, the die was firmly caste, and the government had to all intents and
purposes become a New Zealand First/Labour coalition. Nothing has happened to reverse that over the last few weeks, and
the Prime Minister’s travails with her own Ministers in the last couple of weeks have reinforced the new dynamic.
Against that backdrop, the refugee put down this week is a ruthless assertion to the public of where the power really
lies in this government and who will be calling the shots for the remainder of its term. The Prime Minister's awkward
balancing act from here on is to continue to appear enthusiastic and aspirational, while at the end of her Deputy's
string, and only allowed to implement the policies he mandates. How long the now marginalised public tolerates that
becomes an open question.
ends