INDEPENDENT NEWS

When is a worker a contractor versus an employee?

Published: Wed 1 Aug 2018 10:21 AM
When is a worker a contractor versus an employee?
FIRST Union takes the question to the courts
FIRST Union plans to seek a determination in the Employment Court as to whether courier drivers are employees and therefore covered by employment legislation. The decision to do so follows a two-week long exposure by John Campbell on Radio New Zealand’s Checkpoint of the appalling wages and conditions that many courier drivers work under. The Union plans to overturn the precedent-setting case of TNT v Cunningham and seek a judgement based on new facts and under a new (Employment Relations Act) law from when an earlier decision was made.
Transport, Logistics and Manufacturing Division Secretary Jared Abbott says it was the views of former Chief Employment Judge Colgan on Checkpoint last week that convinced the Union that testing the issue of the employment status of courier drivers (in the Employment Court) was not only the right thing to do, but could have a good chance of success.
“While the legal process may be lengthy, for the sake of these workers it needs to be done.”
Mr Abbott says the Union has been working on the issue for a number of years, negotiating good terms and conditions with several courier companies, but often companies hide behind a contractual relationship rather than an employment relationship despite the drivers being treated as employees.
“Independent contractors, amongst other things, are supposed to be where a person provides a service to multiple companies. But what we are seeing are companies asking courier drivers to be contractors only for them, and to take on responsibility that actually belongs with the company such as insuring the company vehicle and wrapping it with branding, and then paying them net less than the minimum wage for their trouble. We need to stop, and roll back the attempts by some employers to load all employment risks onto their workers.”
He says despite the Union lobbying parliament and making submissions on private members’ bills that could regularise workers (such as courier drivers) as employees, none of the bills made it through parliament.
“It’s very frustrating that when we highlight an issue with the law that is allowing the abuse of the wellbeing of workers, that it’s completely ignored.”
Mr Abbott says in response to the apathy the Union helped establish an owner-driver advocacy service called Pro-Drive that has had some great wins using commercial law, however it has become obvious that the Union needs to challenge the situation through employment law.
“These independent contractors (courier drivers) are in fact employees so we believe we can reach the same successes in case law through employment court.”
He adds a thank you to John Campbell and RNZ for exposing the case and the issues so many courier drivers face.
“The issue is not just one for courier drivers but one for other owner-drivers and independent contractors in many other trades. It is similar to the pernicious labour-hire system that FIRST Union is campaigning against – the latest action being a picket outside a labour hire company in Auckland last week.”
ENDS
First Union
Putting Workers First
FIRST Union is New Zealand's second-largest private sector trade union.
Formed in 2011 after the merger between the National Distribution Union and Finsec, FIRST Union represents 27,000 workers in the Finance, Industrial (Textile and Wood), Retail, Stores, Transport and Logistics sectors.
FIRST Union is also affiliated to the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions and runs several networks including the Union Network of Migrants, the Runanga, Fono and Womens' Committee. In 2015 FIRST Union launched Samoa First Union, Samoa's only private sector union.
Join FIRST Union today for higher pay, better conditions and more say at work.
Contact finsec
Website:
Twitter:
YouTube:
Phone:
0800 863 477
Facebook:
Email:

Next in New Zealand politics

ACT: Regulatory Constitution will improve quality of law
By: ACT New Zealand
Revised offer for teachers and principals
By: New Zealand Government
National supporting primary sector growth
By: New Zealand National Party
On the war purposes of our massive defence spend-up
By: Gordon Campbell
Government supports collective bargaining for film and screen
By: New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
WTF? There’s a giant oil rig on the horizon
By: Greenpeace
Tova O'Brien interviews Act Party leader David Seymour
By: Newshub Nation
New bill will protect freedom of expression
By: ACT New Zealand
ACT launches Freedom to Earn tax plan
By: ACT New Zealand
ACT announces Freedom to Learn education policy
By: ACT New Zealand
National Maori Authority Chair slams David Seymour
By: Maori Council
Proposed 17.5% flat tax would cause economic boom
By: ACT New Zealand
A new offer on the table for secondary teachers
By: PPTA
Primary teachers to vote on a proposed settlement
By: NZEI
National welcomes new offer for teachers
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media