Court of Appeal on Williams And Craig

Published: Mon 5 Mar 2018 06:30 PM
Court of Appeal on Williams And Craig
A The appeal is allowed in part. The order made in the High Court for retrial of the appellant’s claims for liability and damages is set aside.
B Judgment is entered for the appellant in accordance with the jury’s verdict on liability. An order is made directing a retrial of the appellant’s claim for damages.
C In all other respects the appeal and cross appeal are dismissed.
D The respondent is ordered to pay the appellant 50 per cent of costs as calculated for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements. There is no order for costs on the cross-appeal. All costs issues arising in the High Court are to be determined in that Court in accordance with this judgment.
[1] Jordan Williams is the founder and executive director of the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union. Colin Craig was the founding leader of the Conservative Party of New Zealand. Mr Williams is a former supporter of the Conservative Party and its political philosophy of fiscal and social conservatism.
[2] Mr Williams claimed Mr Craig defamed him in statements made in two sequential publications in 2015. Mr Craig’s statements were made in response to Mr Williams’ publicised allegation that Mr Craig had sexually harassed his former secretary. Mr Williams sued Mr Craig for damages in the High Court. Mr Craig ran the affirmative defences of truth, honest opinion and qualified privilege. A jury found for Mr Williams following a trial of nearly four weeks. It awarded him $1.27 million. It was the largest defamation damages award in New Zealand’s legal history.
[3] On Mr Craig’s application, Katz J, the trial judge, declined to enter judgment for Mr Williams in accordance with the jury’s verdict. She later set aside the verdict on the ground that the damages award was excessive. She ordered a new trial of Mr Williams’ claim on both liability and damages, but declined Mr Craig’s application to enter judgment in his favour.
Full decision (pdf)

Next in New Zealand politics

Bill Introduced To Protect Against Conversion Practices
By: New Zealand Government
Govt Welcomes Draft Report On The Retail Grocery Sector
By: New Zealand Government
Poverty Burden For Children Increased Due To Government Neglect - New Report
By: Child Poverty Action Group
NZUS Council Welcomes Nomination Of Senator Tom Udall As US Ambassador To NZ
By: NZUS Council
Visa Extensions Welcomed By BusinessNZ
By: Business NZ
Government Initiatives Contribute To Fall In Benefit Numbers
By: New Zealand Government
Green Party Welcomes Conversion Therapy Prohibition Bill
By: Green Party
Te Pāti Māori Welcomes Announcement Of ‘Ban Conversion Therapy’ Bill
By: The Maori Party
The Salvation Army Supports Proposed Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill
By: Salvation Army
Commission Releases Draft Report On Competition In The Retail Grocery Sector
By: Commerce Commission
Government Plays A Role In Increasing Cost Of Food
By: New Zealand National Party
Commerce Commission Spends Millions Finding Out What We Already Knew
By: ACT New Zealand
Supermarket Competition ‘not Working Well’ For Kiwis – Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media