INDEPENDENT NEWS

Will Labour let Waitangi Tribunal complete TPPA inquiry

Published: Tue 6 Feb 2018 05:27 PM
Will Labour let the Waitangi Tribunal complete the TPPA inquiry?
Labour promised at Waitangi that it will be accountable to Maori. That promise faces a major test next week, as the Crown responds in the Waitangi Tribunal’s inquiry on the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA), according to University of Auckland law professor Jane Kelsey, who was the claimants’ expert adviser in the urgency phase of the inquiry.
In a kitchen video posted on facebook last week the Prime Minister assured New Zealanders that the government ‘has an exemption that says it is always able to legislate and act to protect its obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi and that can’t be challenged by other nations’.
‘Her advisers know that’s not true’, said Professor Kelsey. ‘The Waitangi Tribunal clearly thinks there are still real concerns to be addressed.’
In a memorandum dated 30 January 2018 Justice Doogan, who presides over the Wai 2522 inquiry, set out four questions which the Crown must answer by 14thFebruary:
(a) when will the text of the revised TPPA (the “Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement on Trans-Pacific Partnership”) be available;
(b) what will be the effect of that text on the Crown’s ongoing engagement with Maori on the review of the Plant Varieties regime, and adoption of the UPOV 1991 convention on plant varieties (as required by the TPPA);
(c) what is the legal effect of a new agreement, and what issues remain live for inquiry; and
(d) ‘when would be the appropriate time for the Tribunal to commence inquiry into the remaining substantive claims that have been filed with respect of the TPPA?’
Professor Kelsey pointed to ‘a serious risk that this Treaty-friendly government will repeat National’s dismissive approach to the Tribunal’.
On (a) Trade Minister David Parker has said the text will remain secret, presumably even from the Waitangi Tribunal, until after new agreement has been signed.
On (b), the new government made no attempt to suspend or remove the obligation to adopt the UPOV 1991 convention or find a Treaty-compliant equivalent. That has to be enacted within 3 years of the TPPA-11 coming into force; yet MBIE officials say the review of the current Act will take up to 5 years.
On (c), other aspects of the claim, including significant impacts on water, health, and intellectual property are outstanding.
On (d), National deliberately truncated the time available to the Tribunal to present its first, urgent report. The current government plans to sign the TPPA-11 on 8 Marchand introduce the implementing legislation mid-year, which would terminate the Tribunal’s legal authority to complete the full inquiry before it has effectively resumed.
Professor Kelsey warned that ‘pushing ahead with the TPPA while the Tribunal is still assessing its Treaty implications would be a very bad start to a promising restoration of Labour-Maori relations’.

Next in New Zealand politics

Government To Regulate Vaping
By: New Zealand Government
On The Political Donations Scandals
By: Gordon Campbell
New Zealand: Housing Crisis Requires Bold Human Rights Response, Says UN Expert
By: UN Special Rapporteur
National’s Economic Plan For 2020 And Beyond
By: New Zealand National Party
Right To Regulate Vaping But Wrong To Limit Flavours
By: Vaping Trade Association of New Zealand
Vapers Welcome Risk Proportionate Regulation On Vaping
By: Aotearoa Vapers Community Advocacy
Vaping Crackdown Bill Needs Improvement
By: New Zealand Taxpayers' Union
Pacific Communities Will Benefit From Vaping Bill
By: Tala Pasifika
Vaping Crackdown Condemns Another Generation To Smoking
By: ACT New Zealand
ASH Welcomes Vaping Legislation
By: ASH
Ka Pai To Vaping Bill Announcement - Now It’s Time To Work Together
By: Hapai Te Hauora
Cancer Society Responds To Proposed Vaping Regulations
By: Cancer Society
Statement Of Jami-lee Ross - "Spoke Up Now Set Up"
By: Jami-Lee Ross
Foreign donation loophole still wide open
By: Jami-Lee Ross
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media