New Fisheries Minister’s Decision to Delay Monitoring ‘Fatally Flawed’
Sunday 12 November 2017
Conservation group representatives say a decision by the new Minister of Fisheries, Stuart Nash, to delay implementation
of camera monitoring of fishing efforts in New Zealand is ‘fatally flawed’.
Christine Rose, Chair of Maui and Hector’s Dolphin Defenders NZ, an NGO advocating for better protection of the world’s
smallest marine dolphins, found only here in New Zealand, says “The Government's delay to the introduction of electronic
fishing observer coverage is a huge set back for conservation.
Electronic observer coverage is essential to properly manage by-catch. Evidence from electronic monitoring trials
showed horrific, unreported fish dumping and the death of Hector's dolphins”.
“Robust research from the University of Auckland Business School showed indiscriminate gill net fishing led to the
capture and dumping of non-target species, undersize fish, and endangered dolphins such as Hector’s dolphins, all which
jeopardises the marine ecosystem and undermines this country’s reputation for sustainable seafood”.
“Electronic monitoring of part of the fishing fleet has been a long time coming, and was finally, reluctantly agreed by
the last National Government. It had been considered essential to get on top of by-catch, waste, under-reporting and
non-compliance”. “The National Government was no friend of conservation, but the new Labour government has shown itself
in this move, to be no friend of science, or conservation either”, says Mrs Rose.
“Research shows up to three times as many fish (and non-target species) are caught and dumped than are landed and
recorded in catch records. That’s clearly unsustainable. Electronic monitoring trials proved this point, with clear
evidence of undersize, non-target species caught, and even the capture, killing and discarding of Hector’s dolphins”.
Mrs Rose refers to Operation Hippocamp and Operation Achilles, where observer coverage revealed “appalling’ practices
wasting lives of marine species and squandering resources. “Labour criticised National’s response to the revelations in
these reports, but now in power are making matters worse, pandering to the fishing lobby and putting whole species at
risk”. “Those dolphins, and more, have died in vain”.
Rose says “Minister Nash seems not to have considered all the relevant evidence before making his decision to delay the
observer coverage programme”. “He says he’s made this decision after consulting with stakeholders. But he has been
selective in that consultation as he clearly hasn’t referred to the science, consulted with scientists, or conservation
groups”. “Once again environmental management decisions have been made in isolation, with reference to just one sector,
the powerful fishing lobby, rather than the wider interests involved”.
“Both the Minister, and the new Ministry of Fisheries have failed their first test – with this decision taken in
isolation from historical evidence of dolphin threats, what’s needed for proper, responsible fisheries management, and
wide spread public concern”.
“It’s not what we expected, or hoped for, from the new Labour-led Government”, says Mrs Rose of her organisation and its
supporters. “We’ve asked new Conservation Minister, Eugenie Sage, what the Green Party’s position on this move is”.
“As it was, electronic monitoring failed to cover important fishing impacts from all sectors such as purse seine and
pair trawlers. The 100% observer coverage for Maui dolphins promised by the National Government was never delivered.
Endangered Maui and Hector’s dolphins, and other vulnerable marine species such as NZ sea lions, other dolphins, and
penguins, need more protection, not less”. “Any responsible fisheries manager / Minister would be looking at extending
marine protection and fisheries management, not pulling it back”.
“We encourage the new Minister to live up to this Government’s promise and do more to ensure sustainable stewardship of
our oceans, for Maui and Hector’s dolphins, for the viability of the fishing industry, for the sake of other species,
and for the credibility and integrity of the Labour-led Government”.