18th November 2016
PM clams up about warship visits from nuclear armed countries
The Peace Foundation has made an urgent appeal to the Ombudsman after Prime Minister John Key refused to respond to an
Official Information request seeking information about the visit of the USS Sampson and other warships from nuclear
weapon states until 8 December, well after the warships have left New Zealand. The Peace Foundation spokesperson Richard
Northey said today that: “New Zealanders need and deserve to be reassured that no nuclear weapons are now in New Zealand
during our navy’s 75th anniversary celebrations."
The Peace Foundation made a formal Official Information Request to the Prime Minister a whole three months ago, on
August 15th, after an earlier letter had received an uninformative reply. It requested information about the
decision-making process when the warships were given the go ahead by the government to visit New Zealand, the advice
received and bodies consulted with about the projected visit of a US warship during the current naval exercises
associated with our Navy’s 75th Anniversary. Only yesterday did The Peace Foundation receive a reply from Wayne
Eagleson, the PM’s Chief of Staff, that unilaterally extended the deadline for a response to the Official Information
Act request until 8 December, citing s15A of the Official Information Act (extension of time limits) as grounds for
delaying the response However, the visit by the USS Sampson and other warships and weapons expo currently underway in
Auckland will have well and truly finished by that date.
Peace Foundation spokesperson Richard Northey said today that this failure to respond in a timely way about a matter of
great public interest was intolerable. “The Nuclear Free Act legislation of 1987 is absolutely iconic to New Zealanders
and vital to our safety and security.
New Zealanders have a right to be sure that the Nuclear-Free New Zealand Act is being rigorously enforced and that no
nuclear weapons are being bought to New Zealand on a warship from the US or any other nuclear weapon state."
After receiving no response from Wayne Eagleson to their call early yesterday afternoon, the Peace Foundation formally
made an appeal to the Ombudsman to urgently consider the matter.
“It is urgent that the process, the organisations consulted and the bulk of the documents utilised by the PM and his
advisers in making this decision must be released now. Although the USS Sampson has brought very warmly welcomed
assistance to earthquake victims, New Zealanders have the right to be reassured that it is not also bringing nuclear
weapons. Any incident of nuclear weapons use today, especially given the sheer power of the weapons that are currently
stockpiled, would cause unparalleled destruction far exceeding the magnitude of any natural disaster we have
experienced."
Richard Northey, Chair, International Affairs and Disarmament Committee, the Peace Foundation
Attachments:
Letter from Wayne Eagleson
Letter to the Ombudsman
Subject: Official Information Request relating to US Navy Ship Visit:
Correspondence attached
Dear Sir or Madam,
I am formally requesting your assistance in receiving urgent and timely, and as full as practicable, a response from the
Prime Minister to our letter of 15 August requesting appropriate official information relating to a then proposed naval
vessel visit to New Zealand from the US and from other nuclear weapon states.
The request was made in a sufficiently long time before the visit to ensure that sufficient appropriate information was
released to us on the process of decision-making, the bodies and sources consulted and the advice received and
considered before the visit took place.
It is intolerable that this has not occurred. We and the concerned public have a legitimate right to know whether New
Zealand’s anti-nuclear legislation has been fully complied with. We also need the comfort of being sure that none of the
vessels visiting New Zealand for our navy’s 75th anniversary commemorations are carrying nuclear weapons.
We ask you to intervene urgently and to ask the Prime Minister to release immediately as much information as practicable
now, specifically including at least the process of decision-making; the principles applied in making the decision; and
the people, organisations and sources consulted before these vessels were permitted to enter New Zealand waters.
Yours sincerely
Richard Northey
Chair
International Affairs and Disarmament Committee
Foundation for Peace Studies Aotearoa-New Zealand