7 November 2016
Lessons to be learned from workplace fatality
A workplace fatality involving an exploding bitumen emulsion tank has important lessons for industry according to
WorkSafe New Zealand.
On 30 November last year, an employee of Corboy Earthmovers Limited in Te Awamutu was killed when emulsion was being
transferred under pressure from a transport tank (an “emulsion pig”) to a heating tank. A blockage in the transfer line
caused a build-up of pressure in the emulsion pig.
This caused the rear plate welds to fail, and rear plate swung around and hit the victim.
“The issue here, and what industry needs to be very aware of, is that the emulsion pig was not constructed to take
pressure and nor was there an over-pressure safety device fitted to it,” says WorkSafe Chief Inspector Keith Stewart.
“This company had used pumps to transfer the emulsion up until 2007, and that was a far safer process. When Corboy
started using compressed air it did not identify pressure build-up as a risk and it should have used a properly designed
and constructed pressure vessel – that would have avoided this tragedy.
“Using pressure to transfer materials between containers has inherent risks which must be identified and managed no
matter what the circumstances are, and under no circumstances should containers which are not pressure-rated vessels be
used,” Mr Stewart said.
Corboy Earthmovers was charged under S6 of the Health and Safety in Employment Act with failing to take all practicable
steps to ensure the safety of its employee while at work. The charge carries a maximum fine of $250,000 (This incident
occurred prior to the introduction this year of the Health and Safety at Work Act.)
The company was ordered to pay reparations of $140,319.80 by the Hamilton District Court today. The Judge considered
that an appropriate fine would have been $73,800, but noted that the company is in liquidation so no fine was imposed .