September 14, 2016
UN to examine New Zealand’s approach to child rights
Minister of Social Development Anne Tolley leads a New Zealand delegation to Geneva this week to report on the nation’s
children and whether their rights are being upheld.
UNICEF New Zealand Executive Director Vivien Maidaborn is also in Geneva as part of the delegation and said the child
rights’ agency welcomed Minister Tolley’s attendance.
“We support the Minister’s leadership and direct involvement in closing the gap between the Convention on the Rights of
the Child and New Zealand’s patchy progress to achieve these rights, especially for Māori children.”
“Previous reviews by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) have been extremely critical of successive
governments’ progress for children.”
Ms Maidaborn went on to say this was the fifth such review from the UNCRC but only the first time a minister had led the
delegation.
Non-government agencies such as UNICEF NZ, Action for Children and Youth Aotearoa are also in Geneva for the review,
alongside Judge Andrew Becroft, the Children's Commissioner.
Ms Maidaborn said that alternative reports, written by community agencies and independent advisors, ensure the UNCRC
committee can ask the right questions about government’s activities.
“It’s vital that non-government agencies are in the room to monitor what government tells the UNCRC. The transparency of
the process couldn’t be more vital, both for New Zealanders back home and the international community at large.”
Save the Children, UNICEF NZ and ACYA recently supported young New Zealanders to make their views on child rights known.
This resulted in a report published this week entitled Our Voices, Our Rights which will also inform questions UNCRC ask
the New Zealand government in the exam.
The UNCROC Monitoring Group have felt that in the past only minimal effort has been made by government to consult with
children. These consultations were often adult-led, based around specific policy purposes and didn't include versions
that were child friendly.
UNICEF New Zealand Child Rights Advocate Dr Prudence Stone said 1198 children from all around the country participated
in the initiative and some of the findings were alarming.
“Thirty-eight per cent of children who participated didn’t know what their rights were. Only four children knew it was
actually their right to know, and that government was responsible for ensuring they had this knowledge.”
Dr Stone said the level of introspection and maturity in children’s answers was noteworthy.
“A large majority of children showed concern about serious issues such as inequity within education, inadequate shelter
and food insecurity, as well as the levels of violence that affect children in New Zealand”
Dr Stone went on to say that children even identified possible solutions such as free healthcare for teens, teaching
parents caregiving skills, giving them safe places to go and someone with whom they could talk. Many recognised that
these measures were the responsibility of government.
Children clearly identified four areas as needing more attention from government: Education and educational achievement
(47 per cent), healthcare (35 per cent), safety on the streets and at home (18 per cent), improved housing (17 per
cent).
Dr Stone noted that these responses indicate New Zealand children have high levels of empathy for their peers and are
capable of active citizenship, providing insightful and practical solutions that would ensure all children can live
healthy, fulfilling lives.
ENDS