Property Institute slams Labour Chinese investment claims
Property Institute of New Zealand Chief Executive, Ashley Church, has slammed claims by Labour housing spokesman, Phil
Twyford, calling them ‘reprehensible’ and ‘an exercise in unveiled racism’.
Earlier today Mr Twyford released figures to support his claim that people of Chinese descent accounted for 39.5% of the
property transactions in Auckland between February and April.
However, Mr Church describes the data used by Mr Twyford as ‘shonky’ and says ‘it has so many holes in it that it would
be marked with an ‘f’ if it was submitted as a High School Economics project’.
“Mr Twyford uses ‘asian sounding’ surnames as his means to identify which buyers are ‘Asian Investors’ - without any way
of knowing whether the buyer is a New Zealand immigrant who lives here, or an investor based in China”.
“On that basis Mr Twyford should be blowing the whistle on Scottish foreign investment in this country - because a large
number of kiwi homes are owned by people who have names starting with ‘Mc’ or ‘Mac’”.
“This is the sort of racist sideshow we’d expect from NZ First – not a serious political party with pretensions to hold
the reins of power”.
Mr Church says that Mr Twyfords claims that the Auckland property market is being skewed by non-resident investors may
prove to be correct – but he says that any action taken should be based on hard data and facts – and that the race of
the buyer shouldn’t be a factor.
“We might be surprised to learn who the major investors really are. Work done by the Overseas Investment Office, in
2012, suggested that the biggest buyers were Americans, Brits, Canadians and Aussies – with the Chinese a long way
behind”.
Mr Church says the Property Institute supports the recent move, by the Government, to create a foreign buyer register by
requiring investors to have a New Zealand tax number.
“This will provide good, accurate, information and it will help us to determine whether we need to be taking steps to
ban foreign investment in kiwi homes – or direct it into the construction of new houses, as is the case in Australia”.
ENDS