INDEPENDENT NEWS

Why are we sending women with children to prison?

Published: Fri 5 Jun 2015 11:36 AM
Why are we sending women with children to prison?
CPAG welcomes the latest report from the Families Commission "Improving outcomes for children with a parent in prison"
The costs for children when a parent is incarcerated are very high, with 20,000 children affected.
CPAG commends the Social Policy Evaluation and Research Unit (Families Commission) for highlighting a social problem of immense proportions but very low visibility.
Parents who commit crimes are not the only ones who pay when they are sent to jail. The incarceration of a father can have long term detrimental effects on a child's development. When mothers as principal caregivers of young children are sent to jail the consequences on children can be devastating. This report is a timely reminder of the needs of this neglected group.
CPAG supports the reports recommendation that a review of effective intervention strategies is required. "But we should also be examining why we are sending mothers with children to prison in the first place" says Hannah Anderson. Hannah is a co-author of a recent CPAG report "The complexities of 'relationship' in the welfare system and the consequences for children"
In the CPAG report the pointlessness and vindictiveness of custodial sentences for so called 'relationship fraud' is highlighted. "Sending a mother to prison is a disproportionate penalty, especially when compared with what happens in cases of tax fraud and yet it happens so frequently".
"It costs (the) taxpayers over $100,000 to keep a mother in jail for a year, and the cost of placing her children in alternative care as well. The custodial sentence, or even home detention, often makes it impossible for her to earn to meet the repayments demanded let alone care adequately for her children." says Anderson. "A thorough examination of the whole basis of prosecution for relationship fraud is long overdue. Our policy desperately needs to be aligned with 21st century living arrangements".
- ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Top academics call on government to take climate action
By: UNITEC
New plan for high quality early learning
By: New Zealand Government
Two years’ progress since the Kaikoura earthquake
By: Marlborough District Council
Pike River Mine Drift re-entry plan to proceed
By: New Zealand Government
New High Commissioner to Australia announced
By: New Zealand Government
Dame Silvia Cartwright to lead public inquiry into EQC
By: New Zealand Government
Water rationing in Hawke's Bay as some rivers run dry
By: RNZ
PM pretends climate change isn’t a global issue
By: ACT New Zealand
Minister's Door Closed on Waste-to-Energy Plants
By: Social Credit
Questions remain over Government’s ECE plan
By: New Zealand National Party
Concerned education unions consider joint action
By: NZEI
Education unions' combined executives to meet
By: NZEI
Ministry of Education offers $10,000 to most teachers
By: Ministry of Education
Kaikōura property owners in limbo two years after quake
By: RNZ
Earthquake scenario to practise emergency response
By: Greater Wellington Regional Council
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media