CTU Media Release
18 December 2012
Public surgical centres should not be run by private contractors
CTU welcomes the new dedicated elective (non-acute) surgical centre announced today by Waitemata DHB, but is concerned
that it is being run by private surgical contractors, being paid out of the public purse.
Bill Rosenberg, CTU Economist says “the North Shore Elective Surgical Centre announced today will be good for patients -
more patients get more operations more quickly. But reports that private contractors could be paid over $7,000 per
half-day for the easiest surgery done in public hospitals is a wasteful use of our limited health budget. This is a form
of the Public-Private Partnerships which in the U.K. and elsewhere have led to massive waste of public funds and which
the U.K. government now deeply regrets.”
“In addition, devaluing the work of other hospital specialists who work in other, often more complex parts of our public
health by paying private contractors such extraordinary rates for relatively simple surgery will create conflict and
divisions within the public hospital workforce at the expense of co-operation and teamwork.
“Running this new surgical centre effectively as a private practice effectively means the private surgeons will have
their private practice subsidised by the taxpayer, while only undertaking the easier work.”
Rosenberg says “we support assertions from the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists that this kind of structure
risks the new public hospital elective surgical centre ending up being controlled by a private monopoly, and should not
be the model of funding for our hospitals.”
ENDS