AUCKLAND ACTION AGAINST POVERTY
Media release 29 November 2012, 4pm
Social Security Amendment Bill – Poorly researched and ideologically driven
Auckland Action Against Poverty will present their submission on the Social Security Amendment Bill to the Select
Committee tomorrow morning at 10.35am, says Auckland Action Against Poverty spokesperson Sarah Thompson.
“We will be letting the Committee know that we think this Bill is poorly researched and ideologically driven, and will
go down in history as a cynical, invasive, petty, dishonest, illogical, authoritarian and counter-productive piece of
welfare recession.
“This Bill will change the aim of state welfare from a safety net to a tool of behaviour coercion.
“Those in need of state assistance are going to be asked to jump through hoops that others are not and control over
their lives will be taken away from them.
“Only the noble poor – those deemed morally worthy of our help – will be given help – and they better not make mistakes.
“In addition, punishment will be the main modus operandi of Work and Income. This will not only increase the stress of
already stressful lives but overseas research and experience show that punitive measures will not work. Punishment is
ineffectual in changing behaviour but sure as eggs, it will hurt the vulnerable.
“The welfare system will become an interfering, invasive Nanny State with a big stick – for no gain. Punishment is not
the way to change behaviour.
“We will be letting the Select Committee know that what we need is Decent Job Creation, a living wage, recognition that
care work is real work, a raise in the benefit payment rate and the full reinstatement of the Training Incentive
allowance, not this counterproductive piece of welare recession”.
ENDS