Coal industry poll flawed: Coal Action Network
Wellington, 15 October 2012—The Coal Action Network today accused the coal industry of carrying out dubious market
research to give the impression that there is massive support for coal mining.
The research, done for Solid Energy and released by mining industry lobby group Straterra on Friday, included a set of
questions carefully worded to produce such a positive result.
“The questions appear to be designed to produce a particularly positive set of answers that would benefit the company’s
public image,” said Tim Jones of Coal Action Network Aotearoa. “And we all know how much Solid Energy’s public image
could do with a boost.”
CANA saw the details of the results at a Straterra presentation last Thursday evening.
“I was at the presentation,” said Tim Jones, “and the survey’s own figures don’t back up the spin. According to the
research presented, 71% of New Zealanders would only agree with new coal mining if there was no increase in greenhouse
gas emissions. Since coal mining is a huge source of greenhouse gas emissions, and no viable technology exists to stop
those emissions reaching the atmosphere, that means over 70% of New Zealanders want no new or expanded coal mines.”
“Straterra is using this research to spin to the New Zealand public that we are all champing at the bit for Solid Energy
to start digging up the world’s dirtiest coal, lignite, from beneath highly productive Southland farmland. The figures
don’t back up their story.”
The questions for this year’s poll are available here
Question 14 (see notes below: 1) was particularly misleading.
“On the basis of Solid’s questioning, you could make anyone agree to pretty much anything and produce some fantastic
statistics to it look like the country’s most popular company,” said Jones. “But one particular set of statements are
patently misleading and have no facts to back them up.”
“Many New Zealanders would agree that swimming with sharks was fine -if sharks didn’t bite. Unfortunately, sharks do
bite, and mining and burning coal does produce greenhouse gas emissions.”
CANA has checked the questions with several experts in market research, all of whom agree that the questions are indeed
leading and break some very basic rules of objective market research.
Solid Energy deployed a similar set of questions in its 2009 survey, based on a highly misleading and incorrect
statement that made a still-experimental carbon storage technology look like it was already available. (2)
Yet the technology referred to - Carbon Capture and Storage – has not been commercially deployed, not least because of
the huge costs involved. (3)
“While some may not find it surprising that Solid Energy is carrying out this type of polling, we find it duplicitous of
the company to use leading questions in market research to fool its shareholders – us —into thinking there is more
support for coal than there actually is.”
ends