Office of Human Rights Proceedings: Media statement on Paula Bennett
The Director of Human Rights Proceedings announced today the resolution of a complaint under the Privacy Act against Hon
Paula Bennett, Minister of Social Development.
The Director, Mr Robert Hesketh said, “On the basis of the Minister’s letter to me, I have agreed to close my file. The
matter has been resolved to the satisfaction of all parties. The letter from the Minister is attached. We have all
agreed that the letter speaks for itself and we will make no further comment.”
The complaint had been referred to the Director by the Privacy Commissioner. This is the normal process under the
Privacy Act when the Privacy Commissioner considers a complaint has substance, but the parties cannot agree on a
[The following is a text-recognition version of Paula Bennett's letter generated by Scoop – may contain errors.]
Office of Hon Paula Bennett
Minister for Social Development
Minister of Youth Affairs
Monday, 30 July 2012
Director of Human Rights Proceedings
PO Box 6751
Dear Mr Hesketh,
I have on previous occasions expressed to you through my counsel and to Ms Fuller, when I met with her in person, my
regret at the personal cost that this incident has caused Ms Fuller. The purpose of this letter is to formally convey
I strongly support the right of individuals to participate in and comment on govemment decisions. It is essential to a
functioning democracy. I was therefore pleased that Ms Fuller took the opportunity to express her opinions on the
Govemment’s policy changes.
As you know, I took the view that it was appropriate for me to respond to some of Ms Fuller’s comments in order to
provide what I considered to be information relevant to the public debate that was taking place at the time. I
acknowledge that you consider that I was wrong to do so and that this resulted in a breach of Ms Fuller’s privacy.
As you also know, I do not accept that view. But the purpose of this letter is not to further debate the merits of our
respective positions. What I do want to do is to record my acknowledgment of the personal cost that the resulting public
debate has caused Ms Fuller. I was personally shocked and concerned by the unpleasant, hurtful and personal comments
some members of the public made about Ms Fuller. I am also distressed that such comments have been repeated following
media reports about Ms Fuller’s complaint. Individuals who participate in public debate should not be subject to that
kind of treatment. It was certainly never my intention that Ms Fuller would find herself in that unpleasant position.
I understand that Ms Fuller wishes to move on with her life and to put this unfortunate incident behind her. I hope that
she is able to do so and that this letter may help to bring this matter to a close.
Given that this matter has attracted such a high level of media and public interest, it seems sensible for this letter
to be made public to ensure the accuracy of any commentary and to bring the matter to a close by avoiding any ongoing
media speculation. I understand that Ms Fuller is happy for that to happen. To that end, I confirm that if asked about
the matter I will direct the questioner to this letter. I trust that the media and other interested parties will respect
Ms Fuller’s desire to move on with her life and to stay out of the public spotlight. I wish her all the best for the
Hon Paula Bennett