Crafar Farms sale approval surprising only in that it took so long to rubberstamp
The announcement today of Ministerial and Overseas Investment Office approval of the sale of the bankrupt Crafar Farms
to Chinese buyers is no surprise to the Campaign Against Foreign Control of Aotearoa (CAFCA). The only surprise is that
it took them so long to rubber stamp it. This was all supposed to be a done deal back in 2010 when it was supposed to be
sold to the first lot of would be Chinese buyers. That all turned to custard because of an even greater of lack of good
character than usual of the company’s principals, who are now facing serious criminal charges in Hong Kong (but nothing
in New Zealand, which tells you a lot about the diligence of NZ’s “regulatory” authorities).
So it became not only an embarrassment but a political hot potato, one which exposed deep rifts within National’s
supporters and within the Government itself, at the highest levels. It was parked up out of sight until after the
election. But it has still taken a further two months to find the cans of air freshener with which to mask the stink of
what is yet another huge sale overseas of New Zealand’s comparative advantage in the global market – prime agricultural
land (of which they ain’t making no more).
The lily is being gilded by the announcement that Landcorp will manage it on behalf of the Chinese buyers. Everyone
knows that there is the world of difference between being the owner and the property manager. Ownership is power; owners
make the decisions (including onselling it); owners get the profits.
The lily is being further gilded by a number of conditions being attached to it (Labour set the precedent for this in
regard to the equally controversial Shania Twain land purchases when it was in office). Conditions such as the buyers
remaining of good character (this could be renamed the May Wang clause) and paying millions of dollars to various worthy
causes. These should be taken with a well deserved grain of salt. Why? Two words – Kim Dotcom.
The Prime Minister keeps issuing soothing noises about foreign land purchases only totaling around 1% of the total land
area. He is being disingenuous. What is important is what percentage of the total area of productive land is
foreign-owned. These statistics are no longer issued by the Overseas Investment Office but when they were, last decade,
CAFCA calculated the figure at 7% - and it was never officially denied or disputed. We’ve seen no evidence of that
figure having gone down, quite the opposite. Plus the PM is stressing quantity when, once again, the key factor is the
quality of the land being flogged off overseas. Foreign buyers are cherrypicking, not buying the rubbish (that’s left
for the locals).
CAFCA stresses that the race of the buyers is irrelevant. Flogging the Crafar Farms overseas is reprehensible regardless
of whether the foreign buyers are Chinese, Americans, British or Australians. Despite attempts to reorient the economy
into other directions (finance companies, anyone?), New Zealand still remains an agricultural country. And we’re very
good at it, which is why foreign buyers want to snap it up.
CAFCA doesn’t carry any flag for Michael Fay’s rival bid. All we need say about him is that patriotism is the last
refuge of the scoundrel. The opportunity to have the Crafar Farms genuinely stay in local hands was lost when the
receivers rejected Landcorp’s bid to buy them (which gets the management contract as a consolation prize).
The Prime Minister said in 2010, when controversy was raging about the original Chinese proposal to buy these farms;
that he didn’t want to see New Zealanders become tenants in our own land. A commendable sentiment, one with which CAFCA
completely agrees. But today’s decision by his Government ensures that is exactly what is happening.
CAFCA
Campaign Against Foreign Control of Aotearoa
ENDS