Manu Caddie - amendment to media statement

Gisborne District Councillor Manu Caddie says the proposal announced by Minister for the Environment Nick Smith is a step in the right direction but will be largely dependent on the details of the new law and how the new Environmental Protection Agency interprets its mandate.

Previous Mayor of Wellington Kerry Prendergast has been appointed the Chairperson of the EPA. "Kerry is a good friend of the National Party, given her record on environmental protection, I don't have much confidence in the regime while she is in charge" says Mr Caddie. "With someone like that in charge the process is likely to be largely a rubber-stamping exercise for business to do whatever it wants to with some token oversight from a friendly EPA."

The lineup suggests a group of people who are likely to be fairly sympathetic to the plans of business interests.

Minister Nick Smith says "The balance of economic and environmental skills reflects National’s Bluegreen approach of supporting growth and protecting the environment”.

In other words the threshold of what constitutes 'more than minor effects' on the environment is likely to be set very high and all but the most damaging ideas will get the green light.

On 2/06/2011, at 2:41 PM, Manu Caddie wrote:

> MEDIA RELEASE
>
> 2 June 2011
> A vocal critic of government policy on offshore drilling in the Raukumara Basin says he cautiously welcomes the announcement that a new bill will be introduced this year to establish regulations on minerals exploration and extraction beyond the Territorial Sea.
>
> District Councillor Manu Caddie says the proposal announced by Minister for the Environment Nick Smith is a big step in the right direction.
>
> “I take issue with his statement that what happens beyond the 12 mile limit has less effect on local communities, a large oil or gas leak in the EEZ would have a massive impact on the Coast.”
>
> Mr Caddie says that provided the legislation has provisions at least as robust as the Resource Management Act, he believes it is a positive development.
>
> “It is pleasing to see that where a proposed activity spans the boundary between the territorial sea and EEZ, local government would have a joint role with the EPA in decision-making.
>
> “The devil will be in the detail in terms of things like a substantial bond can be put in place before any drilling starts in case something goes wrong. We have seen overseas when a major spill happens the issue can be tied up in court for decades and the taxpayer foots the cleanup bill and no one is held to account. Requiring a billion dollar bond up front seems fair to me and should be easy to do for companies with a good reputation.”
>
> Mr Caddie says he is also concerned about the process the EPA will use for determining what activities are determined to be permitted, discretionary or prohibited. “The Minister says seismic testing is likely to be permitted but we will make sure the EPA has access to evidence demonstrating the significant impact seismic testing has on some marine life during their regulation-setting decisions.”
>
> “This proposal obviously doesn’t address the fundamental issue of fossil fuel extraction and the problems that creates for the country and the planet.”
>
> ENDS
>

© Scoop Media