No. 431 February 2011
Climate Adviser Misses the Point
From The Economist
11 February 2011
In his recent report on Weighing the Costs and Benefits of Climate Change Action, Ross Garnaut argues that urgent action
to reduce emissions by setting a carbon price would be in Australia's national interests.
To reach this conclusion, the report considers the costs and benefits to Australia of emissions reduction. It should be
commended for doing so, as that brings vital discipline to the debate. Yet even accepting the report's account of the
science, its assessment overstates the benefits of immediate action and understates its costs and risks.
The difficulties arise even if one assumes that effective international agreement on mitigation is reached, allowing
Australia to reap long-term benefits from mitigation efforts. As the report recognises, it would still need to be
established that those benefits outweighed costs.
Whether that test is met is affected by how costs, incurred now, and benefits, decades away, are converted into a
comparable measure in the present. There are no easy answers as to how this should be done. It is obvious, however, that
no one would accept an offer to invest $1 today in a project that would return only $1 70 years from now.
This article was published by the The Australian on 11 February 2011.
Articles in the Perspectives series plus a large library of books, studies, speeches, articles and DVDs on a wide range of public policy issues can
be found at www.nzbr.org.nz
Related studies and commentary:
The Climate Change Scare is Dying, But Do Our MPs Notice?
A report published by the New Zealand Business Roundtable
8 December 2010
By Christopher Brooker
The Business of Climate Change
An article first published by New West
13 April 2010
By Pete Geddes
A Few Notes on Climate Change
An article first published by the Cato Institute
18 December 2009
By Andrei Illarionov
Submission on the Climate Change Response (Moderated Emissions Trading) Amendment Bill
A submission by the New Zealand Business Roundtable
October 2009
The Economics and Politics of Climate Change: A Cool Look at Global Warming
The 2007 Ronald Trotter Lecture
15 November 2007
By Nigel Lawson
Stern Review on Climate Change is Bad Economics
An article first published in The Otago Daily Times
27 January 2007
By Roger Kerr
The Real State of the World
The 2003 Ronald Trotter Lecture
8 October 2003
By Roger Kerr
If you have received this email from a friend or colleague and wish to subscribe, please click here. If you wish to unsubscribe from the Roundtable mailing list, please click here.
ends