25 January, 2011
NZ must speak out against 'slap on wrist' sentences for Indonesian soldiers guilty of torture
The Indonesia Human Rights Committee is deeply shocked at the light 'slap on the wrist' sentences just handed down to
the three soldiers who have admitted responsibility for the brutal torture of two Papuan farmers. IHRC is calling on
Foreign Minister Murray McCully to make a strong protest to the Indonesian authorities as this outcome shows blatant
disrespect to the victims, the Papuan people and international law. IHRC also renews it call on the New Zealand
government to suspend its defence training ties with Indonesia.
"Minister McCully has a strong responsibility to act because he was given assurances that the matter would not be swept
under the carpet when he met with Indonesian Foreign Minister Natalegawa in Jakarta last year,'said Maire Leadbeater
speaking for IHRC.
The sadistic and prolonged abuse[1] was caught on video and was widely circulated on 'YouTube' last October. In the
YouTube segment one of the victims has his genitals repeatedly burnt with a fiery stick while the other has a plastic
bag placed over his head.
'Sentences of only between 10 and 8 months for these perpetrators are not just. The men were only charged with
disobeying orders' and were tried in a military court which cannot be considered impartial. They are even free to
continue with their careers.'
"It adds insult to injury that President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has publicly stated that the offences were a 'minor
matter' and even complained because of the extent of international attention given to the case.'
This shocking travesty of justice is a further indication of the lack of reform and ongoing impunity in Indonesia's
security forces. New Zealand was wrong to resume defence training ties with Indonesia in 2007 and these ties should now
be suspended.
For further information: Maire Leadbeater ;
25 January, 2011
Hon Murray McCully, Minister of Foreign Affairs, Parliament Buildings, Wellington.
Dear Murray McCully,
The Indonesia Human Rights Committee is deeply shocked at the light 'slap on the wrist' sentences just handed down to
the three soldiers who have admitted responsibility for the brutal torture of two Papuan farmers.
The perpetrators were given light sentences given of only between 10 and 8 months. They were only charged with
disobeying orders and were tried in a military court which cannot be considered impartial. They are even free to
continue with their careers. This is a travesty of justice
We urge you to make a strong protest to the Indonesian authorities as this outcome shows blatant disrespect to the
victims, the Papuan people and international law. We recall; that during your visit to Jakarta Indonesian Foreign
Minister Natalegawa assured you that this shocking episode would be fully and transparently dealt with.
We believe that this unjust outcome is a further indication that the Indonesian military has not undergone democratic
reform and that the culture of impunity remains entrenched. New Zealand was wrong to resume defence training ties with
Indonesia in 2007 and these ties should now be suspended.
The 'YouTube' video showed one of the victims having his s genitals repeatedly burnt with a fiery stick while his
companion has a plastic bag placed over his head. Tunaliwor Kiwo , one of the victims has since given video testimony
that he was tortured for two days, by being beaten, held over a burning fire and by having a concoction of chillies and
detergent rubbed into his wounds.
We believe it is outrageous that President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has publicly stated that the offences were a 'minor
matter' and even complained because of the extent of international attention given to the case.
We look forward to hearing from you about this distressing matter and to learning the details of New Zealand's response.
Yours sincerely,
Maire Leadbeater (for the Indonesia Human Rights Committee)
ENDS