10 June 2004
No to Dobson dam – NZCA
The New Zealand Conservation Authority is opposed to any law change to enable approval of the Dobson dam proposal.
“A unique remaining stand of lowland native forest would be flooded if the dam went ahead,” Authority acting-chairperson
Marian van der Goes said today. “It is of such high ecological value, and is legally recognised as such, that the
Conservation Minister would be unable to approve the proposal unless a law change were made.”
“The point of the Conservation Act is to prevent irreplaceable conservation land being lost forever, because of
knee-jerk reactions to perceived crises.”
The Card Creek Ecological Area was gazetted in 1983 to protect a unique valley floor stand of regenerating podocarp
forest, including kahikatea, matai, rimu and totara, as well as kaikawaka (mountain cedar).
The area contains the richest known native birdlife in North Westland, on the basis of species diversity and abundance,
and includes: kereru, weka, yellow-crowned kakariki (parakeet), ruru (morepork) and karearea (falcon).
“The value of the Card Creek Ecological Area is so high that it was extended twice by the Conservation Minister, in 1997
and again in 2001,” Ms van der Goes said. “This last addition was land formerly managed by Timberlands.”
“The Dobson issue is not about swapping one piece of land for another to satisfy conservation concerns. Land swaps are
not applicable in the case of ecological areas. The 394 hectares of forest at stake is unique in New Zealand.”
Even if a swap were possible, Trustpower’s proposal of Mt Buckley was unacceptable because it was relatively common hill
slope beech-hardwood forest, not rare valley floor podocarp and kaikawaka forest, Ms van der Goes said.
The area to be flooded is 10 per cent covered in gorse, not mostly covered in gorse as some project proponents had
incorrectly claimed, Ms van der Goes said. The gorse-covered areas were the result of former logging and mining
operations and were now regenerating to native forest.
“The Conservation Act was passed to ensure that the environment, which defines our national character as New Zealanders
and provides us with inspiration and enjoyment, is protected for future generations – and that includes when the going
gets tough.”
Background
The New Zealand Conservation Authority is made up of 13 members representing a wide range of interests, and they include
business, legal, and environmental experts. The authority is appointed by the Government to provide independent advice
on conservation issues to the Minister of Conservation.
ENDS