Hon Anne Tolley
Minister for Social Development
18 August 2016
Media Statement
New ministry to focus solely on vulnerable children
E nga mana, e nga reo, e te iwi o te motu, tena koutou, tena koutou, tena koutou katoa
Good morning everyone and can I thank you for the invitation to be here today. I’d like to acknowledge:
Brendan Boyle, MSD Chief Executive
Sue Mackwell, National Children’s Director
Murray Edridge, Acting Deputy Chief Executive, Child, Youth and Family
Greg Versalko, Sarah Parker and the Hub team
Liz Thomas, Counties Manukau Children’s Team Director
Kathleen Atkins, acting Hamilton Children's Team Director
And, of course, all of our hard-working staff who devote every day to keeping our children safe.
It is a real pleasure to be here with you today as we celebrate the first anniversary of the Vulnerable Children’s Hub.
Many of you will be aware that one of the themes that came out of the public submissions on the Green Paper for
Vulnerable Children was that people were cautious about calling CYF when they had concerns about a child or young
person’s safety.
Contacting the authorities was seen as a serious step, if someone couldn’t be absolutely sure that some form of abuse
was taking place.
But people need to be encouraged to come forward if they suspect a child could be at risk.
The idea for the Hub came from this. It acts as a kind of triage system, directing the concerns to the most appropriate
agency or service, based on the level of support a family needs.
At this stage, it is available for professionals to use and is linked to the three Children’s Teams using the Vulnerable
Kids Information System, or ViKI.
This means that if a teacher, a doctor or a school social worker has concerns about a child or young person they can
contact the Hub and the decision is made in the Hub whether Child, Youth and Family, the Children’s Team or an NGO is
best placed to help this family.
In the last year, the Hub has accepted referrals for 1071 children and taken 1397 contacts and calls from professionals
in Hamilton, Christchurch and Counties Manukau.
985 of these children and young people were referred to a Children’s Team, where all of the professionals involved in a
child’s life contribute to a single plan, and a single lead professional ensures that plan is carried out so that they
don’t go on to need statutory intervention.
I want to thank everyone involved for their efforts so far. You are making a real difference in keeping our children
safe. So congratulations and happy birthday to the Hub.
And this is an important day for care and protection. Because today I am announcing that from April 2017 a new,
dedicated child-centred Ministry will be in place to focus on the safety and long-term well-being of our most at-risk
children and young people.
Cabinet has agreed with the advice we have received, which found that given the significance and scale of the proposed
reforms to state care and protection, a stand-alone ministry is most likely to provide a single point of accountability,
clear organisational focus and the ability to attract strong leadership.
It will also have a new Chief Executive. The State Services Commissioner has today announced that Grainne Moss will take
up this vital role next month.
And as the panel stated, strong leadership is going to be key to the successful delivery of a bold, new model to better
serve our children and young people.
Grainne, who will sit on the Vulnerable Children’s Board, will also need to lead a huge culture change but she’ll be
well served by her previous public and private sector experience.
It’s almost a year and a half since I appointed an independent expert panel, and a youth advisory group, to advise me on
a complete overhaul of our care and protection system.
The panel’s first report concluded that the whole system needed to change to better support children and to better
support staff to do their job, instead of spending over fifty per cent of their time on admin.
The panel found that CYF was not effective in intervening early to provide the support that these children and young
people deserve, and that subsequently demand for CYF services has increased as a result of children re-entering the
system on multiple occasions.
The average age of children placed with family is 7 to 8 years old and they have already had an average of 7 to 8 care
placements by this stage. The trauma these children face with each new placement is unthinkable.
And we must not forget the shocking study which found that by the age of 21, for children with a care placement who were
born in the 12 months to June 1991:
Almost 90 per cent are on a benefit
Around 25 per cent are on a benefit with a child
Almost 80 per cent do not have NCEA Level 2
More than 30 per cent have a Youth Justice referral by age 18
Almost 20 per cent have had a custodial sentence
Almost 40 per cent have had a community sentence
We can’t go on like this. Staff don’t need me to tell them that there have been numerous well-meaning restructures and
quick-fixes over the years.
It hasn’t made any difference. The system is not working for children. And they are the only thing that matter.
So, following the delivery of a detailed business case from the panel, Cabinet agreed to a long-term radical overhaul of
our care and protection system.
This is no knee-jerk reaction. It is a once in a lifetime opportunity to make a real and lasting difference. We are
determined that it will succeed. It won’t happen overnight. It will take years. But it must be done.
The new system will address the short and long-term wellbeing of at-risk children and support their transition into
adulthood. It will no longer focus solely on crisis management.
It will focus on five core services – prevention, intensive intervention, care support services, transition support and
a youth justice service aimed at preventing offending and reoffending, and will have the ability to directly purchase
vital services such as trauma counselling as soon as they are needed by children. There will be more high-quality
caregivers, and better support for these families who open their homes to our most vulnerable children.
The new Ministry will be responsible for statutory care and protection, youth justice services, adoption services, the
Children’s Action Plan directorate and Children’s Teams, Community Investment relating to funding and contracting for
vulnerable children services, family and sexual violence services relating to child victims or perpetrators, current
complaint services and policy advice.
It will be reviewed after two years, during which time it will share some corporate services with MSD, to allow the new
department to focus on operational issues.
As I’ve said before, it won’t need fewer staff – quite the opposite. We will need more people with specialised skills.
The new Chief Executive will put a leadership team and management structure in place. The new way of working, and the
culture change required, will need strong leadership and management.
Meanwhile front line social workers will move over to the new model to ensure it is ready to go on day one in April next
year. As the new operating framework is rolled out over the following 4-5 years, staff will need a different mix of
skills and will receive the necessary training. It is not simply CYF under a new name.
And it will have a new name. It is a completely new Ministry. This sends a message that we are serious, it is not the
same as CYF and has a very different way of working. But the new name won’t help a single child – it is how the agency
operates which will make a difference for children.
The new department will be called the Ministry for Vulnerable Children, Oranga Tamariki.
Oranga Tamariki for the health or wellbeing of children. And it is significant that this aspirational te reo is included
in the name. 6 out of ten children in care are Maori and the new Ministry will have a strong focus on improving the
lives of Maori children and their families – and indeed all children.
Meanwhile the other part of the name reflects the fact that we have had a green paper for Vulnerable Children, a white
paper for Vulnerable Children, we have a Vulnerable Children’s Act, a Vulnerable Children’s Board, and of course we are
here today at the Vulnerable Children’s Hub.
One of the issues with CYF was that its core business was sometimes blurred.
This new name makes it crystal clear that it exists to support and protect vulnerable children. That is its only job. We
cannot shy away from this. We can’t hide it and dress it up as something else. We are determined to tackle this head on.
And I’ve heard a lot about stigma. Well, stigma comes when you’ve been in care and end up in prison, or on a benefit, or
don’t have any qualifications. And too many young people who leave our care system end up in that position. We are going
to change that. Other people can focus on the name – I’m going to focus on producing a system that gives our children
the lives they deserve.
Work is continuing apace on the new model, with a transformation team working on its introduction, supported by $200
million of initial new investment in Budget 2016, and taking place alongside normal CYF operations which have received
an extra $144 million for cost pressures.
This includes the transformation programme team engaging with cross sector and community stakeholders over the next two
months, such as government agencies, NGOs, iwi, young people, families and caregivers, as part of service and co-design
work. They’ll be focusing on national care standards for caregivers, early enhancements to care, transition support
services to help young people into independence once they leave care, and the practice framework for the new operating
model.
I’m expecting to receive options within the next couple of months on the shape of the new independent youth advocacy
service, and I want to thank the young people, NGOs and our philanthropic partners who have been involved in the design
work so far.
The strategy to engage all New Zealanders so that communities can get more involved in the support of vulnerable
children continues to be developed, while the second tranche of legislation to support the overhaul is being prepared.
Significant legislative changes are currently going through Parliament which will raise the age of state care and
protection to a young person’s 18th birthday, ensure that children’s voices are heard in decisions which affect them,
and which will establish an independent youth advocacy service.
For too long the needs and opinions of children and young people in the care system have been ignored. The new Ministry
needs to be totally child-centred – and to do that it must include the voices of children. And I’m delighted to say that
I have appointed a new Youth Advisory Panel, made up of young people who are in or who have experience of state care, to
advise me and the transformation team in the months ahead as we design the new system. The original Youth Panel provided
very valuable input while we developed the case for change and the detailed plan for the years ahead.
And there are other significant decisions that have to be made if we are truly serious about keeping children safe.
One of those is around information-sharing, so that the new Ministry can be well informed of any factors that affect a
child’s welfare.
We will continue to ask communities to be vigilant and to make authorities aware if they suspect that something is not
right within a household.
And of equal importance – agencies, NGOs, DHBs, and professionals must share information if they have knowledge which
can stop a child from being abused.
I know that privacy can be a major concern for professionals. But I make no apologies for believing that a child’s
safety comes first every single time.
At the moment, many professionals are unclear about what information they can and can’t share, and with whom. Sharing
information is optional. It’s at their discretion.
If the default position is not to share, then there could be serious consequences for a child. There have been too many
cases in the past where a child has suffered because many different agencies or professionals have had little bits of
information that no one has shared or put together, which could have made a difference.
We need to be more proactive. Everyone involved needs a clear legal framework which sets expectations about sharing
information concerning the safety and welfare of a child – and only this information – and which gives them the
confidence and protection to do so.
I believe the default position needs to be that any information concerning a current or future possible danger to a
child needs to be shared.
Children must always come first.
Minister Adams and I have had initial advice on what this framework could look like and which organisations and
individuals would be involved. The next step will be to take a paper to Cabinet.
So there are many big changes and huge challenges ahead over the next few years. And yes, it will take years.
That shouldn’t frighten us. We need to embrace this. It is a wonderful opportunity to do the very best we can for
vulnerable children and young people.
We all have a role to play. And we must get it right this time.
Congratulations again and thank you for all the work you do to keep our children safe.
ends