Key wrong to use cyber protection to justify spying
John Key is trying to scare and confuse New Zealanders by saying mass surveillance by the GCSB is needed to achieve the
country’s cyber protection, the Green Party said today.
The Green Party in Government would look to remove the cyber protection functions from the GCSB and put them into a
separate agency solely focused on that activity.
“Our cyber protection is undermined by being carried out by spies. What we need is a separate agency whose 100 percent
focus is on ensuring our cyber protection,” said Green Party Co-leader Dr Russel Norman.
“Mass spying and cyber protection are two separate issues. It is wrong for John Key to justify mass surveillance as
being necessary for cyber security, it is not.
“Cyber security is a real issue, and getting it right is critically important to New Zealand; however it is essentially
unrelated to international spying which is the core function of the GCSB.
“If you are a business and you have a cyber-security problem, you need absolute assurance you can get help from the
government’s cyber security agency which has a single focus – on helping you with cyber security.
“Because the GCSB is responsible for both our spying and cyber protection it is easy for the lines to get blurred. In
the middle of a cyber-attack, a company should not have to second guess if its data is going to get used for other
purposes by the very agency that is supposed to be helping it.
“We know that one of the purposes of the US government’s spying is to further trade and financial interests by helping
US companies compete with overseas companies.
“Because all information collected by Five Eyes partners can be shared between them, there is a real risk that companies
facing a cyber-attack, who go to the New Zealand government’s cyber protection agency inside the GCSB, will have their
information shared with the NSA and their offshore competitors.
“The Green Party has always said that a separate agency, free from spying, should be in charge of New Zealand’s cyber
“In Government we will undertake a wide ranging independent inquiry into New Zealand's intelligence agencies, and we
will specifically look at separating cyber protection from the GCSB,” Dr Norman said.