Bill English
National Party Finance Spokesman
Media Release
19 August 2014
Greens plainly wrong again on Budget claims
Russel Norman and the Greens have again confirmed they cannot read Budgets, repeating incorrect claims that the
National-led Government is planning multi-billion dollar cuts to health and education spending over the next three
years.
“If I was Russel Norman, I’d ask BERL to cancel the invoice for their latest report on behalf of the Greens,” National
Party Finance Spokesman Bill English says.
“The forecast health and education numbers they quote for future years exclude allocations yet to be made from future
annual operating allowances for discretionary spending and they also exclude capital investment allocations.
“These decisions are made by ministers just before each Budget – as they have done under successive governments.
“Typically health and education receive most of this extra discretionary operating spending.”
In Budget 2013, the Vote Health allocation for 2014/15 was in the accounts at $14.1 billion. After Budget 2014
decisions, the total health budget, including discretionary spending and capital investment, was actually $15.6 billion.
“This process happens every year, but Dr Norman obviously doesn’t know that - yet he wants to be finance minister one
day.
“Although the Greens are again wrong with their numbers, they also fail to understand that it is the results of spending
that matter for New Zealanders – such as lower crime and higher educational achievement.”