Oral Questions July 22 - 1 Transcript
1. Prime Minister—Statements
1.
Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS (Leader—NZ First)
to the Prime Minister : Does he stand by
his statement: “We have a plan, and that plan is working
for New Zealand.”?
Rt Hon JOHN KEY (Prime
Minister): Absolutely !
Hon
Member : Just a few of them.
Rt Hon
Winston Peters : You will hear it in the campaign,
son.
Mr SPEAKER : Order! Supplementary
question, the Rt Hon Winston Peters. [Interruption]
Rt Hon Winston Peters : Well, you think
manual labour is the Prime Minister of Mexico, don’t you?
Mr SPEAKER : Order! The interjections
coming from the right-hand back of the House will cease.
Rt Hon Winston Peters : Thank you for
bringing order, Mr Speaker. If the plan is working, why are
well over 148,000 Kiwis unemployed and a further 100,000
seeking much more work than they have currently got?
Rt Hon JOHN KEY : Firstly, the
unemployment rate in New Zealand is falling. The
participation rate in New Zealand is dramatically
increasing. I would be a bit cautious about quoting those
numbers, because that is off the household labour force
survey and it indicates anybody who is looking for 1 hour of
work or more.
Rt Hon Winston Peters :
If the plan is working, why is New Zealand’s total
international debt at a staggering $150 billion?
Rt Hon JOHN KEY : It depends on how the
member is measuring that, but I would indicate that, of
course, over the last 5 or 6 years the Government has
borrowed. If the member is going to come with me down to
Christchurch and tell the people of Christchurch that New
Zealand First does not care about them and would not have
borrowed money to support them, then I really look forward
to the member standing next to me and saying to the people
of Christchurch: “It’s common sense just to leave you
behind.” A National Government would not do that.
Rt Hon Winston Peters : If the plan is
working in what a former Prime Minister called a
property-owning democracy, why is homeownership at its
lowest percentage rate since 1951? [Interruption]
Mr SPEAKER : Order! I want to hear the
answer.
Rt Hon JOHN KEY : We might
dispute the fact, but what we can say is that the Government
has a comprehensive plan that is actually starting to work
in relation to homeownership, and if the member wants to
support us in terms of reform of the Resource Management
Act, which will allow us to speed up that process even more,
again, he should feel free to come over here and put his
warm little hand in mine and together we can sing a song. It
is common sense to have reform of the Resource Management
Act.
Rt Hon Winston Peters : If the
plan is working in a country where a former National labour
Minister knew the name of every unemployed person because
there were only 29 of them, how come 22 percent of Māori
and 25 percent of Pasifika people aged between 15 and 24 are
unemployed in their own country?
Rt Hon JOHN
KEY : I think that the time at which a Minister of
Labour could name every single person who was unemployed was
the time when moas were around in New Zealand. I do not
think that has worked terribly well. But the reality is that
the Government has been investing heavily in a range of
areas to deliver economic growth and it is working for New
Zealand.
Rt Hon Winston Peters : If the
National Party was “working for New Zealand”, why would
it have to say it and spend millions in public relations
trying to hawk that delusional message?
Rt Hon
JOHN KEY : The party is running a campaign message
that it is working for New Zealand because that reflects a
Government that over the last 6 years has worked very hard
for the people of New Zealand across a wide range of areas.
It also reflects a party that has received significant
support from New Zealanders on the back of the fact that
they do believe, in fact, that it is working for New
Zealand.