INDEPENDENT NEWS

Zaoui victory welcome, SIS must open to scrutiny

Published: Thu 13 Sep 2007 03:20 PM
13 September 2007
Zaoui victory welcomed, SIS must be opened up to scrutiny
Green Party MP Keith Locke is delighted by the decision to withdraw the risk security certificate against the Algerian refugee Ahmed Zaoui, and has called for both genuine parliamentary oversight of the SIS and less use of secret evidence in future.
"This is a great victory for Ahmed and his family, for his lawyers Deborah Manning and Rodney Harrison QC, and for a court system that consistently found Ahmed's human rights were being infringed by a secretive and unfair process," Mr Locke says.
"Ahmed Zaoui's success benefits the civil liberties of all New Zealanders, by making the Government more accountable as to who it labels a 'security threat'. The so-called 'war on terror' has given too much power to the executive arm of government.
"The Refugee Status Appeals Authority that found Ahmed to be a genuine refugee in August 2003 has been fully vindicated - and the Government could have saved Ahmed a lot of grief, and taxpayers a lot of money, by embracing the RSAA decision four years ago. The Immigration Minister has always had the power to withdraw the security risk certificate at any time. Instead, the Government backed the SIS throughout.
"It should be kept in mind that Ahmed's legal team were initially- and shamefully - denied access to the allegations against him. The Zaoui lawyers were only able to expose the shabbiness of the SIS case because they fought and won in court the right to a summary of the SIS evidence. Forced to show its hand, the SIS scoured the world for further evidence to discredit Ahmed, and finally fronted up only in July this year - at which point, the SIS case fell apart.
"The SIS now has a new leader, Warren Tucker, more committed to openness than his predecessor. The Government should now ensure the security services receive the level of genuine parliamentary oversight common in Australia, the US and the United Kingdom. It is disgraceful that the special committee currently supposed to provide this oversight in New Zealand has met for a grand total of two hours and 38 minutes since the 2005 election.
"The Government should also now drop those parts of its new Immigration Bill that envisage wider use of secret evidence in immigration decisions. The use of inaccurate, speculative secret information in the Zaoui case lies at the heart of the injustice that has been done to the Zaoui family - who can surely now expect to be speedily re-united in New Zealand.
"Secret evidence must be made capable of being speedily tested in open court. If that had been done in 2003, this fiasco would have been avoided. The Government must now commit itself to striking a better balance between national security and individual rights - otherwise, there will be further injustice done to other Zaouis in future," Mr Locke says
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

National Selects Emma Mellow As Auckland Central Candidate
By: New Zealand National Party
Update on New Zealand and the Cook Islands travel bubble
By: New Zealand Government
Speech: Ardern - Let’s Keep Moving - 2020 Election Campaign Launch
By: New Zealand Labour Party
On Political Twins, And On Labour Extending Its Wage Subsidy Scheme
By: Gordon Campbell
Adjournment Debate: Speaker Trevor Mallard
By: Hansard
Vaping Legislation Passes
By: New Zealand Government
Overall, 82% Trust Pandemic’s Management – Down From 91%
By: Horizon Research Limited
National Releases 2020 Party List
By: New Zealand National Party
How Judith Collins stopped the bleeding
By: Horizon Research Limited
Your Vote 2020: Bringing Election Coverage To Viewers Across TVNZ Channels And Platforms
By: TVNZ
30% Believe Households Worse Off, 298,000 Expect To Lose Jobs
By: Horizon Research Limited
Findings Of Investigation Into COVID-19 Active Cases Privacy Breach
By: State Services Commission
New Zealand suspends extradition treaty with Hong Kong
By: New Zealand Government
Judith Collins on Roger Bridge allegations: 'It's not something I approve of'
By: RNZ
Emma Mellow selected as National Party candidate for Central Auckland
By: RNZ
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media