Collins Comments
24 August 2007
New Zealanders were sickened when little Nia Glassie – aged 3 – was brutalised and later died in hospital. Many New
Zealanders felt that her death was, ironically, a respite from what had clearly been an unmerciful, cruel and short
life. Most of us wondered at how anybody could be so evil to a child. Most of us wondered at what has happened to
sections of our communities that every 5 weeks, one of our babies is killed, usually by those charged with loving and
nurturing them.
It is very easy to put money into welfare and into “programmes”. It’s not so easy to understand the mindset of those who
are so lacking in empathy and so devoid of human decency and kindness that they will kill a child. What is even less
easy is to stop making excuses for such people, to identify and then prevent the abuse.
We were told by the proponents of the anti-smacking law that this law would stop child abuse. It hasn’t. It won’t. We
were told that those of us who have smacked our child on the hand or bottom for being naughty or unruly were, at worst,
child abusers and, at the least, condoned “beating our babies”. We weren’t and we aren’t. Now with John Key’s
intervention, the Police are required to use common sense in deciding whether or not to prosecute – something that was
missing from Sue Bradford’s bill.
We need to understand how someone becomes a child abuser - not to make excuses, but to try to stop babies being killed.
There are common markers for child abuse. We know that these incidences primarily occur in what is called “dysfunctional
families”. James Whakaruru, Coral- Ellen Burrows, Nia Glassie, Soleil Aplin and Olympia Jetson (to name only a few)
lived their short lives in severely dysfunctional homes. The families are normally well known to Child Youth and Family
and the Police. They usually consist of loose personal relationships, intergenerational welfare dependency, drug and
alcohol addictions, intergenerational child abuse including child sexual abuse, criminality, truancy, poor literacy and
numeracy, lack of empathy for others, despair, lack of personal responsibility and a reliance on a variety of government
departments. Mix all these together, add a child, and we have a recipe for disaster.
In the meantime, a group of parents have organised a march against child abuse this Saturday, 25 August, at 10am in
Queen Elizabeth II Square, Queen Street, Auckland. Indications are that the Children’s Commissioner and government
agencies won’t attend. Apparently, the organisers are so politically incorrect as to call for harsher sentences for
child abusers. Should abusing a child be elevated to a principal factor in sentencing? Of course it should. I’ll attend
the march and you might like to be there too.
ENDS