Jacinda, THAT tweet, and Gaza
by Julie Webb-Pullman
The New Zealand Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ (MFAT) tweet
on 12 November condemning rocket fire from Gaza while failing to condemn the Israeli extrajudicial assassinations and
civilian killings that generated Islamic Jihad’s rocket-fire in defensive response, reveals the hypocrisy at the heart
of New Zealand’s so-called “even-handed” foreign policy and practice towards Palestine.
The message of the MFAT tweet is clear – Palestinian lives do not matter to the current New Zealand government. The
Gazan lives lost in the past week are somehow considered less worthy of protection or comment than the Muslim lives in
Christchurch so rightly mourned, and the loss of which were condemned throughout the country, and the world.
Our Prime Minister garnered much positive PR mileage nationally and internationally for her principled response to that
terrorist attack by an individual – but the MFAT tweet suggests state terrorism is a different kettle of fish.
It wasn’t always so.
Given the threat that atmospheric nuclear testing in the Pacific posed to Pacific citizens’ health and rights, NZ’s
third labour government led by Norman Kirk bravely took on the French government not only in the International Court of
Justice, but also by sending a NZ navy frigate into the nuclear testing zone with a Cabinet Minister on board
in 1973. (France ceased atmospheric testing the following year.)
Such warrior-like behaviour was not without fallout – the French government blew up Greenpeace anti-nuclear protest ship The Rainbow Warrior in Auckland
harbour twelve years later. This time it was the fourth NZ Labour government that stood strong, exerted our right to an
independent foreign policy even against some of our closest allies, and again held France to account. (Two French agents
served time, and our exports to Europe were protected.)
Twenty years later it was Israeli muscle most publicly and notably felt in NZ when, in 2004, two Mossad agents, Uriel
Kelman and Eli Cara, were caught attempting to fraudulently obtain New Zealand passports.
These more recent gross violations of both New Zealand sovereignty and international law were met with both anger and diplomatic sanctions
by Prime Minister Helen Clark and the fifth NZ Labour government, as well as earning six-month jail sentences from the
courts for the two captured agents - and another soon-to-be-broken Israeli promise to cease the faking and misuse of
foreign passports for its terrorist activities (following as it did a previous promise after the 1997 incident in which
Mossad agents used fake Canadian passports in an assassination attempt in Jordan on Hamas leader Khaled Maashal,
resulting in the Israeli ambassador being ordered out of Canada. Similarly, the promise to NZ to desist was soon broken
in 2010, with the assassination in Dubai of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh by Mossad agents using fake British, Irish, French,
German and Australian passports... Israeli misuse-of-passport promises are seemingly as reliable as their word on
This week, even more blatant Israeli violations of international law and the right to life have taken place in Gaza. But
instead of the condemnations we became accustomed to from NZ governments when the aforementioned serious breaches of
human rights and international law occurred, this week’s response more resembles that of a cowed Israelophile, than that
of a country upholding the rule of law without fear or favour.
It reflects the type of intimidation that almost every New Zealand broadcasting or media outlet informally reports
having been subjected to by the Zionist lobby, in the form of endless vexatious, frivolous or trivial complaints
designed to deter coverage of any and every Palestinian issue, an intimidation also familiar to potential political
candidates, politicians, academics, activists and ordinary citizens everywhere when supporting Palestinian
self-determination, or criticising Israeli government policy or practice.
It accepts and ignores the brutality experienced daily by Palestinians going about their lives in the West Bank and
Jerusalem, the brutality confronting each Gazan daring to protest along the fence, to resist, or to exercise their
legitimate right to self-defence.
Every Gazan home right now has children cowering in fear, along with their families, unsure where the next bomb will
fall and who it will take with it. There are no shelters in Gaza; NOWHERE is safe.
It is now up to New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Adern to step up to that tweet, and demonstrate the sort of
leadership we rightly expect - to show us that donning the hijab after the Christchurch mosque attacks was not just the
type of senseless and theatrical gimmick the 1973 frigate protest was accused of being.
Gazans are people.
Most, if not all, of those killed in Gaza this week were Muslims. Over 30% were women and children.
Come on, Jacinda - show that their lives matter, too.