$160k worth of seedlings mulched in project botch-up

Published: Tue 13 Nov 2018 03:13 PM
Jo Moir, Political reporter
About 400,000 seedlings bought by the government to plant in Northland have gone to waste after the land was too wild to plant on.
Photo: RNZ / Richard Tindiller
Forestry Minister Shane Jones said the cost to the taxpayer was about $160,000.
A deal was done between the Crown and the Ngāti Hine Forestry Trust in the Far North earlier this year and 1.2 million seedlings were bought to be planted.
Mr Jones said only 200,000 seedlings were successfully planted because the land wasn't up to scratch.
"Well the land is untamed land, it's wild, and obviously the analysis that was done on the ground was a lot more ambitious in terms of what could be delivered upon,'' he said.
About 600,000 of the seedlings were re-distributed to other forestry ventures - many of which are with iwi and have existed for many years.
Mr Jones said he'd been clear with officials involved in the botch-up that it's not good enough.
"I'm certainly not trivialising $160,000 for people all around New Zealand and particularly in the North - that's a huge sum of money," he said.
"The officials will be giving an account of who did what and why it's turned out this way. Rest assured I'm not sweeping this under the carpet and that's why I'm speaking publicly about it."
The 3500 hectares of Ngāti Hine land will be "substantially planted in the upcoming season but naturally I'm disappointed that such a number of seedlings had to be mulched because the land couldn't be prepared in good time.''
Mr Jones said part of the problem was the government was elected in October and planting started four or five months later and "perhaps those targets were too ambitious''.
In August Mr Jones announced Cabinet had approved the creation of a new grants programme and partnership fund to get more trees in the ground and provide training and employment opportunities.
The Provincial Growth Fund, which Mr Jones is the minister in charge of, is allocating $240m to support tree planting in areas where "wider social, environmental, and regional development goals can be achieved''.
Documents released by Treasury reveal they were highly critical of the grants and fund and said as much in a briefing paper to the Finance Minister Grant Robertson.
Officials said there was "little detail" that came with the Budget bid and they didn't support Cabinet approving it.
Mr Jones said Treasury gave some "predictable cautionary remarks", which he's taken into account.
The details had been worked through since that briefing paper and he said he's confident Treasury's concerns have been covered off.
The greater details of the partnership fund and grants programme will be released later this month.
Ministers James Shaw, Eugenie Sage, David Parker and Mr Jones have all been involved in the work.
Mr Jones said Treasury "prefers to see the whole picture before an in principle decision is made'' but Cabinet was never going to give final sign-off unless all the details were worked through, which they now have been.
He said the grants had a "long and rich history" and they've existed over successive governments.
"It's not as if we're starting from scratch - the Ngāti Hine situation is challenging not just because of the tameless nature of the land, including the owners - but the fact of the matter is we're starting from a very low base because the Crown has been out of this sort of business for nigh on 25 years,'' he said.
New Zealand's public broadcaster, providing comprehensive NZ news and current affairs, specialist audio features and documentaries.
Radio New Zealand is a Crown entity established under the Radio New Zealand Act 1995. Radio New Zealand News are vital elements in our programming, providing impartial news and information to New Zealanders every day. Radio New Zealand (RNZ) provides listeners with exciting and independent radio programmes in accordance with the Radio New Zealand Charter.

Next in Comment

20 Years of the Scoop Information Ecosystem
By: Joseph Cederwall
Lyndon Hood: Better Analogies for National Pilfering Budget Data
By: Lyndon Hood
Were journalists 'just doing their job' in the political resignation of Metiria Turei?
By: Sean Phelan and Leon Salter
Gordon Campbell on the extradition of Julian Assange
By: Gordon Campbell
NZME hits 10,000 paying subscriber target early
By: BusinessDesk
Budget 2019 - Scoop Full Coverage
By: The Scoop Team
Julian Assange as Neuroses
By: Binoy Kampmark
The Effort to Relabel Julian Assange
By: Binoy Kampmark
Shredding Asylum: The Arrest of Julian Assange
By: Binoy Kampmark
Terms of Asylum and Distraction: Moreno’s Assange Problem
By: Binoy Kampmark
Grand Jury Efforts: Jailing Chelsea Manning
By: Binoy Kampmark
How You Can Be Certain The Charge Against Assange Is a Fraud
By: Caitlin Johnstone
10 Reasons Assange Should Walk Free
By: David Swanson
WikiLeaks Founder Charged in Computer Hacking Conspiracy
By: United States Department of Justice
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media