Gordon Campbell on the Greens bad deal over the flags
Click for big version.
So thanks to the Greens, the Red Peak design has now been added to the options for the flag referendum in November. Wow. In one fell swoop the
Greens’ Gareth Hughes has (a) rescued Prime Minister John Key from his personal flag fiasco (b) got the government out
of a tight corner of its own making (c) agreed to vote with National to block Labour’s attempt to get a yes/no question
added to the November referendum and (d) handed the Key government a club with which to beat the only other party –
Labour – with which the Greens can hope to form a government in 2017. Was Red Peak such a compelling cause that the
Greens needed to expend so much political capital on it?
Surely, the principled position for the Greens was to continue to treat the flags campaign as a costly diversion by a
government tone deaf to a tanking economy and to those in genuine need. It should have left Labour and National to slug
it out. Instead, the Greens seem to have decided that a few hours in the spotlight was worth the risk of being seen as
National’s saviour. Unfortunately, yesterday’s gambit has also gone some way to retrospectively validating the bogus
campaign that Labour ran in the last few days before the 2014 election….ie, when it tried to scare voters that the
Greens would support National in government. Come 2017, all Labour will have to do is point to the flags campaign to
make the same point again. Crikey. Where was Clint this week when they needed him
(Answer : working for Labour.)
On the upside… according to new co-leader James Shaw, this decision enables the Greens to sensibly transcend party
politics and end the standoff between the two major parties on the flag issue. Hmmm. Throwing your weight behind the
government isn’t a neutral position. Surely, the claim to have transcended party politics looks a bitnaïve, when Gerry
Brownlee is already taunting Labour with the outcome that the Greens have made possible. It is not as though the Greens
came up with a novel, deal-breaking position: instead, it has simply delivered the government the escape route that it
wanted, on terms where it is agreeing to enable John Key to block Labour’s attempt to stop more money being wasted on a
second referendum in March. Shaw has spent all year denying the allegations that he’s really a closet Nat in disguise.
Yesterday’s effort won’t help on that score.
I know, I know… the poor old Greens get damned for playing the populist card over flags, and damned when they don’t -
and then end up looking like killjoys over the Rugby World Cup. Surely though, if you’re going to put populism over
principle, you need to ensure that the “populist” position you’re taking really is a popular one. In this case, the
Greens have put themselves on the unpopular side of the flags argument in almost every way. Red Peak isn’t a choice so
overwhelmingly popular (yet) as to justify the entire manoeuvre.
Meaning : there is every sign – some of it reflected in polls only last week
– that the public didn’t want anyone to ride in and save the flag referendum. They want to bury it. Given the options,
the public prefer to keep the current flag, Red Peak or not. And the public really don’t want to pay the full $26 million for the two referendums that the Greens have now ensured they will have to
underwrite in full.
Footnote : Populism can be hard work. Over the RWC bars issue, what the Greens failed to do was to link their principled concerns
with the important pressure groups ( eg the Police) who were equally pissed off with the Act Party’s wet kiss to the
liquor industry. In the end, the Police were left all alone to mount a rearguard action on the eve of the RWC
and try to warn the public about the kids going to school at the same time as fatigued, liquored up rugby fans are
getting out of bars, and climbing into their cars. That’s how you frame a populist argument – by getting respected
allies on board - even when you’re up against rugby fanaticism with a beer chaser. “Greens do deal with National over
flag referendum ” is not a populist position. Or much of a principled one.
Dogs and videos
In my own craven concession to populism last week, this column linked to Sebadoh’s supremely cool and aloof cat in the
video for “Ride The Darker Wave” … In order to transcend the petty politics of cat people versus dog people, here now
are a couple of great videos with dogs in them.
For a starring role by a single dog in a music video….. this video for “ Feel You” by Julia Holter is pretty great. This
cut is from her new album Have You In My Wilderness that’s due for release on Friday.
Of course, the all time greatest dogs-in-videos track is still “Poney Part One” the early 2000s dance item by DJ