MEDIA RELEASE
For immediate use
26 July 2018
Whitecoat website forcing doctors into dubious business relationship
“The Whitecoat website that rates doctors is looking more and more dubious on closer examination,” says Ian Powell,
Executive Director of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS).
“It seems that doctors can be added to the website without their permission and the only way they can then have any
semblance of control over what appears is if they then go through a process of ‘claiming’ their profile, which the
website says they might then be charged for.
“If they do claim their profile, they can then decide not to show any comments by patients – but members of the public
looking at the profile will be told that they have chosen not to show comments.
“Either way, whether they are listed on the website with their permission or without it, the doctor cannot opt out of
the website. They are essentially coerced into a business relationship with Whitecoat that could be potentially harmful
for them professionally or personally.”
Mr Powell was commenting on the FAQs section of the www.whitecoat.co.nz website that allows patients to rate their doctors and leave comments (https://whitecoat.co.nz/#/faq).
ASMS has also raised concerns about the potential for unfair treatment of doctors (https://www.asms.org.nz/news/asms-news/2018/07/26/website-to-rate-doctors-a-serious-concern-questions-asked-about-fairness-safety-and-vested-interests-of-health-insurance-companies/).
“There may well be doctors who think this is a useful initiative to sign up to as part of a wider marketing plan for
their practice or clinic. They should be aware, though, that once on the website, there’s apparently no getting off.”
Mr Powell also noted several concerning features about Whitecoat’s privacy policy, also on the website at https://whitecoat.co.nz/#/privacy-policy.
“This policy makes it clear that Whitecoat will collect whatever information they can about a doctor, from whatever
source available (including past or present employers), but may not have to share that personal information with a
doctor even if asked to do so.
“The true underlying intention of the website is apparent in this privacy policy as it refers to using the information
it holds to, among other things, contact health care providers to promote services or products, and to help other third
party service providers contact doctors.
“This website has a lot of pitfalls for doctors and other health care professionals, and we think it needs some closer
scrutiny.”
ENDS