Sunscreens Test Shows Need for Regulation
Consumer NZ’s latest test of sunscreens highlights New Zealand’s situation of classifying sunscreens as cosmetics is not protecting consumers and needs to
change.
Consumer NZ chief executive Sue Chetwin says out of the 19 products tested, only nine sunscreens met their SPF label
claim and the requirements for broad-spectrum protection.
“As a result of our test two ‘natural’ sunscreens, which only provided low protection, and a third product, which didn’t
meet its high protection or broad spectrum claims, have been removed from sale,” Ms Chetwin says.
Consumer NZ’s test also found six other products, including some big brands, that didn’t meet the SPF claimed on the
label. However, Ms Chetwin says most of the affected companies were able to produce lab results showing the products had
been tested and met their label claims.
The exceptions were the Cancer Society and Sungard. Consumer NZ’s testing of the Cancer Society Everyday SPF50+ and
Sungard Moisturising Sunscreen SPF50+ found they had an SPF of 40 and 45 respectively. The sunscreens still provide high
protection but not the very high protection indicated by the SPF50+ label claim.
This isn’t the first time Consumer NZ has found differences between its test results and the manufacturers’. Consumer
organisations in Australia, the US and the UK have also reported similar findings.
“Companies don’t have to regularly test their products to ensure they still meet SPF claims, even if an ingredient
supply changes, and some companies may go for years without re-testing. Our testing has also highlighted the lack of
consistency between labs even when products are tested the same way,” Ms Chetwin says.
Another concern is that sunscreens can be sold in New Zealand without being tested because the sunscreen standard is
voluntary. In a country with one of the highest skin cancer rates in the world, it’s time the government made the
Australia and New Zealand standard mandatory, Ms Chetwin says.
For the full test results check out the December/January issue of Consumer or consumer.org.nz.
ENDS
Consumer NZ is a non-profit organisation. In addition to our product tests, we investigate consumer issues and campaign
to improve consumer rights. But we're not government-funded and don't take advertising, so we rely on revenue generated
from membership to fund our work in getting all New Zealanders a fairer deal. Consider supporting us today. Join us, and
become a member atconsumer.org.nz